Monthly Archive for April, 2008

‘Please let us come home’ pleads father in Philippines adultery case - April 21

From Andrew Drummond,

Bangkok

Sunday April 20th 2008

A Briton, who fled the Philippines with his girlfriend and baby daughter to avoid being jailed on adultery charges, said today (Sunday) that he would undergo DNA tests in Bangkok to prove that he was the baby’s father.

And he begged British officials to allow him to go home with his new family to start a new life.

scottd08 Thailand 1David Scott, 36, from Swindon, a Ministry of Defence sub-contractor specialising in armour, fled

Manila after being told by the British Embassy that his daughter – Janina- who was born while he was on the run from authorities was not legally his.

Officials said Janina, now three months old, who Mr. Scott brought to Bangkok with his girlfriend Cynthia Delfino, was under

Philippines law, the daughter of Cynthia’s husband Noriel, from whom she had been separated for three years. Divorce is illegal in the Philippines.

The couple met on an internet Facebook style site while Cynthia Delfino, 28,  was working as a supervisor at a hotel in

Abu Dhabi. She initiated proceedings to annul her marriage and the husband agreed.  But he stopped proceedings when he found the couple’s picture on the internet.

Delfino then angrily brought adultery charges against the couple who were arrested on December 30 last year and imprisoned.  They faced seven years in jail for adultery and Noriel Delfino could have claimed the baby.

Having been bailed and on the run  Noriel who took a second adultery charge out so that their bail would be withdrawn.  The couple had to live in derelict houses and even a banana plantation for fear of re-arrest.

The couple claimed they had to pay bribes for bail totalling £6000 for documents to get out of the country and to Philippines Immigration 03David Scott 1officials.

“At the moment we are stranded in Asia. I cannot leave my sweetheart and baby behind. I am pleading with the British government to allow us all to come home.

“We are hoping someone back home has a heart.”

The couple have recruited the support of their local M.P. Anne Snelgrove (Swindon South). They hope their application will succeed outside the laws of the Philippines.

Link: Evening Advertiser

Briton charged with adultery flees Philippines with baby - Daily Mail 21/04

British father who fled Philippines begs the government to let him bring his family to UK - Daily Mail

 Safe: Dad facing jail for adultery - Sunday Mirror April 20 08

Link: Why wont the Foreign Office help? Mail on Sunday

 

 

From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok

 

A British father, who faces seven years jail for adultery, has successfully fled the Philippines with his new born baby daughter to save her being taken from him by local officials.

 

David Scott, 36,  who spent the New Year locked up in Manila with his Filipina girlfriend Cynthia Delfino after being arrested at gunpoint – was last night safe in with his new family Bangkok.

 

scottd05 Thailand“He’s my Superman,” his girlfriend and mother of his baby, Cynthia Delfino: “It’s so good to be free at last, and that’s down to him, but our future is still uncertain.  I have to throw myself on the mercy of the British government to be with our baby” .

 

Said David Scott. “Now I can fight without my hands tied to bring my daughter home.”

 

The couple escaped with their baby Janina, after a three month ordeal during which they said they were locked up in a squalid cell smeared with blood and human excreta forced to live in the jungle and derelict houses forever in fear of re-arrest and blackmailed by greedy officials seeking to cash in on their dilemma.

 

For David Scott, he said, it was a race against time to stop the authorities in the Philippines taking his child away from him. For under Philippines law the baby was not legally his.

 

Legally, although he was the natural father, little Janina Scott, belonged to Noriel Delfino, Cynthia’s husband who had agreed to an annulment, but changed his mind when he saw David was a foreigner and sent in a bill for £7000 for ‘loss of face’ instead.

 

“I was not going to let him or the authorities take away my daughter – over my dead body!” said David in Bangkok.

 

When David flew in to the Philippines late last year to prepare for his baby’s birth he was ‘on top of the world’.  The husband, who had been separated from Cynthia for three years, had agreed to an annulment (Cynthia and David were paying)  and David was looking forward to becoming a dad.

 

Their world was shattered on December 30th when armed police, immigration officials and officers of the National Bureau of Investigation stormed their house in Caloocan, north of the capital Manila, accompanied by the husband.

 

Said David, 35, a technician working on sub contracts for armour the Ministry of Defence: “ Our house was surrounded and all the police had drawn weapons on us. I have never seen so many guns. You would have thought we were terrorists.

 

“When we were taken to the police station a policeman pointed to one of the police vehicles, which was full of bullet holes, and said to me with a laugh: ‘I took the guy who did this round to the back of the car and put a bullet in his head’.

 

“They charged us and put us in a large cell with scores of others.  Then Cynthia negotiated a cell of our own. We had to pay an extra £10 per night to be alone together.

 

“The wall of our cell was covered with blood and human excreta. It was filthy and rats would come and go as they pleased.  Three days later were eventually offered bail of about £150, but we had to pay over £1000 under the table just to get it.

 

“I could see this case was not about right or wrong. It was about who could make money out of it.

 

scottd06“As soon as we got out of sight we just ran. We were in contact with the Embassy by phone. We lived rough in a derelict house, with friends, and some nights in a banana plantation, cooking over a wood fire. We were terrified of being re-arrested.

 

“We knew the husband did not care about his divorce or Cynthia, he just wanted the money. He wanted to get us back into jail because there we would be vulnerable and probably be happy to pay to get out. 

 

“But the fact is my money had run out.  Everywhere we turned bribes were demanded and I was not going to be blackmailed any more. I felt like an escaped prisoner of war. I could not go out in public because I might be recognised.”

 

David’s call to the Embassy confirmed just how much trouble they were in. Officials told him that even though he was the baby’s natural father, legally the Embassy had to abide by the law that said the child belonged to Delfino.

 

The response was followed by the usual Foreign Office comment in such cases: “We cannot interfere with the law of our host country.”

 

But after taking up the case with his M.P. Anne Snelgrove (Swindon South) the Embassy did a u-turn saying that if he could produce a birth certificate, and provide DNA tests witnessed by Embassy officials the child could obtain British citizenship. But process could take up to eight months!

 

But with only days left before his re-arrest David, he had no choice but to flee.  Together with Cynthia and two month old Janina, born in a private clinic while on the run, he bribed Philippine officials to get him onto a Philippines Airlines flight to

Bangkok.

 

Said Cynthia:  “We did not get out a day to soon. On the day we left we heard at the airport that police had issued another warrant for our arrest because my husband had taken a second case of adultery against us both in another court.

 

But before we left I had been summonsed to the family court to give evidence in my annulment case. But the judge did not even turn up.

 

“But my husband and his family were there and my lawyer and I were tailed by their private detectives. They followed us everywhere and it was difficult to shake them off.

 

“Eventually after two hours my lawyer called my husbands lawyer and told him to call off the detectives, because no matter how long it took we would never show them where we lived.

 

“It’s good to be out and safe with our baby. But this means I cannot go back to the Philippines. They will not give me bail again and I will be jailed for adultery.

 

“The only crime I am guilty of is sleeping with the man I love. My husband and I had been separated for a long time. It was he that sent me to work as a supervisor at a hotel in Abu Dhabi and told me to send money home. All he did was sit at home and wait for the money.”

 

Tomorrow Monday the couple will go to the Police Hospital in

Bangkok for DNA tests to prove without any doubt that David is the father.

 

British officials say they do not need to witness the DNA tests as the system is more reliable than in the

Philippines. But the couple are taking no chances.

 

David met Cynthia, a psychology graduate, on and internet Facebook style site while she was working as a supervisor at the Emirates Palace Hotel in Abu Dhabi.

 

He knew she was married and separated but their relationship developed and in April last year she became pregnant during a holiday together in the Philippines.  She initiated annulment proceedings against her husband, Noriel Delfino, who initially agreed.

 

Scott said he had to bribe government officials £2,500 to provide a genuine birth certificate and £2,100 for a passport from his baby.

 

“I am free and penniless and have been supported by my mum and some very good friends.”

 

The real costs since December had been £13,000 which included paying bribes of over £1000 under the table for bail of only £150, payment to police to be able to sleep together in the same infested cell, £4000 for passports and documentation,  £500 in bribes to get out of the country, plus £4000 in legal fees.

 

03David Scott“Even though we had paid Immigration officials, when I left the Passport Officer said that he believed my entry visa to the

Philippines was forged.   When his colleague pointed out that the signature was actually his he just mumbled and took my last £25 anyway.”

 

The couple have received widespread support in the Catholic Philippines, where divorce is illegal and annulment, the only alternative, is seen as a device for the rich only. In all annulments one of the parties has to admit he or she is ‘psychologically incapable’.

 

The Manila Standard newspaper described their case as ‘a sad commentary on an antiquated Philippine adultery law, on corrupt police officials, and on the ordeals of David Scott’s love - a woman who was eight months pregnant but had to spend several days in a putrid and cramped jail cell.’

 

Philippines Human Rights lawyer Katrina Legarda said: “I  have tried for 20 years to introduce a sensible divorce law, but every time I do I get condemned as a friend of the devil in pulpits all over the country.”

 

In Swindon David’s mother Anne Scott, 60, said: “I’m so glad they are safe now from bullying officials.  I just want to see my grand-daughter, son, and Cynthia as soon as possible. I wish David’s father were still alive for this happy event. And I hope the Foreign Office will understand they are a genuine case.

 

“Before this David had hardly missed a day’s work in his life.”

 

Added David ‘Mum has seen our baby on an internet web cam several times. She cries whenever she sees Janina.

 

Open letter from Aaron Quill on the jailing of his father in Thailand - April 16 08

 To the posters at ThaiVisa .com

Dear All,

My name is Aaron Quill, Kevin’s eldest son.

I would like to say thank you (to most of you at least!) for your support over the past 8 years (and now), what happened in the court was an absolute shock to myself, my family and all who know my dad. At a time like this, it is inevitable that the rumour mill will go into overdrive and the “no smoke with out fire” merchants will come crawling out of the woodwork. all I can say to this, is that it is one hel_l of a lot easier to slag off a man who cannot defend himself.

I must also stress, that 6 years in a thai jail would be a terrible punishment for any man-whether he is guilty or innocent, as you will all know thai jails are not like prisons in the uk. However, 6 years in a thai jail to an (innocent) man, who now has a hole in his throat following throat cancer, is in fact, a death sentence.

I understand that some of you know my Dad, and his stance against drugs, which he despises. I visited a bar in Pattaya yesterday, and was overwhelmed by the number of well wishers that all know that my Dad was framed (by 2 very high profile and wealthy FARANGS) that offered their support. I understand that I cannot name the 2 men responsible, but all I can say is that they have a very chequered past, both here and in the UK-Should you wish to find out more, a british journalist working in thailand has reported on their “dodgy dealing” on a number of occasions. His name is Andrew Drummond, and if you google his name, you will get a better insight into the minds of these twisted, evil crooks, as you will be able to read some of his work. It reads like a Hollywood movie-you have murder, corruption and greed.

Anyway, I have not come here to slate my dad’s ex-business partners. Some of you will not know the full story, and I can appreciate that many of you will read this and say to yourself ” this is coming from his son, surely it’s going to be biased”. All I ask is that you look at the facts before you judge, and nail an innocent man to the cross.

For example;

My dad has been back to the UK numerous times since his arrest-And returned to Thailand EVERY TIME. Why did he not stay in the UK?Surely these are not the actions of a guilty man? With his connections and wealth, it would be easy to start afresh.

I have been advised by the british embassy not to be drawn into online arguments, in case I am misinterpreted as criticising the Supreme Court, and therefore the King (hence my careful wording).

One of you has clearly not read the facts properly, and got it into your head that my Dad is scottish, and blackmailed a scottish judge-His ex business partners are from Edinburgh and Falkirk respectively! For the record, my Dad was born in Halifax, West Yorkshire, and later moved to Bradford where he made his name as a successful businessman.

I would also like to say thank you to the man who has stated that although he doesn’t like/think he’d like my Dad, he doesn’t believe that he would have commited the crime he was accused of. It is opinions like this, which are unbiased, and shows that even people who dislike my dad are shocked at what has happened.

For those of you that are shocked at the verdict and wish to help, i would appreciate it if you could contact me on my personal email which is aquill789@yahoo.co.uk

Yours faithfully,

Aaron Quill

Links: Thai Visa Thread

Fighting for Justice
 

Thai P.M. orders investigation into tourist killings - April 10 2008

Leo Del Pinto charcoal 1 2 3Thai Prime Minister orders investigation into tourist killings

From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok
April 10 2008

Thai Prime Minister Samak Sundaravej today (Thursday) formally ordered an investigation into the conduct of a Thai policeman who shot dead a Canadian tourist and injured a second.

The Thai Premier, in his role as the Chairman of the Department of Special Investigations, ordered the DSI to formally investigate charges of murder and attempted murder.

The move comes in the midst of allegations that police in Pai, a picturesque tourist village in northern Thailand, deliberately attempted to cover up the actions of one of their own officers, whom they had to investigate.

The case was taken up by the Thai Human Rights Commission. Commissioner Saisuree Kosolnavin and a team found evidence that completely contradicted the investigation conducted by Police Colonel Sombat Panya of the local Pai police.

Colonel Panya claimed that Canadian Leo Del Pinto, 24, from Calgary and Carly Reisig, 24, from Chilliwack, B.C. had made an unprovoked attack on Police Sergeant Uthai Dechawiwat after he broke up a fight between them in January this year.

Uthai, he claimed, shot in self defence as he fell to the ground. His automatic had a hair trigger.

The police story was subsequently published in the local press and the wire stories and transmitted worldwide.

Police further said that nevertheless Sgt Uthai had been charged with murder and attempted murder but on investigation there was no court record of such charges.

Witnesses and forensic evidence examined by Thailand’s leading pathologist Dr. Pornthip Rojanasund however totally contradicted the police story. 

Forensic evidence showed that the policeman shot down into Del Pinto’s head. Witnesses said that Sergeant Uthai pistol whipped Ms Reisig before shooting her under her left breast.

The conduct of the police had earlier been referred by the TNHRC to the country’s Anti-Corruption Commission.

Dr. Saisuree said: “This development is very encouraging. The process has already started as Ms. Reisig and another witness have been allowed to give evidence in court.”
 

Irishman’s death on round the word tour linked to heroin - Irish Independent April 5 08

Link: Irishman’s death on round-world trip linked to drugs - Irish Independent

By Paul Melia and Andrew Drummond
Saturday April 05 2008
The body of a 32-year-old Co Louth man who died in Thailand after allegedly taking a cocktail of drugs is expected back in Ireland today.

Police said yesterday they had closed the file on the death of Elliot Blake (32), blakee01who died while on a round-the-world trip with his girlfriend.

Mr Blake, who was understood to be living in Navan, Co Meath, died in a guest house in the early hours of last Monday after he was found staggering on the street.

His girlfriend, Claire Duignan (23), from Westmeath, woke in the Top North guest house in the northern Thai capital of Chiang Mai to discover his body.

Despite efforts to revive him, he was pronounced dead at the scene.

Police in Thailand said yesterday there was no evidence of foul play in Mr Blake’s death. However, the results of a post- mortem have not been released.

The Department of Foreign Affairs confirmed his death, and said it was providing assistance to his family. A spokeswoman refused to comment further, saying it was a private matter.

His girlfriend told police that Mr Blake had been a heroin user in Ireland, and had acquired the substitute methadone from a local hospital.blakee03

“Earlier in the evening we went out for some food and a few drinks, but nothing much,” Ms Duignan said yesterday.

“We came back to the guest house and I went to the room, while Elliot stayed downstairs watching TV.

“When I left him he was quite normal, then much later when he didn’t come back to the room I went looking for him.

“I found him on a nearby road staggering back to the guest house. He was completely different from when I left him and I had to help him back to the room. When I woke up I didn’t realise he had died. I poured water on his face to wake him up but it didn’t work.

“We’ve been travelling for a year now, Elliot used to use heroin in Ireland but since we’ve been traveling he hasn’t. When we got to Chiang Mai he went to a hospital and got some methadone.”

It is understood Mr Blake may have combined methadone with valium, which led to his death. Chiang Mai is a popular destination with backpackers.

Mr Blake’s family travelled to Thailand earlier in the week to arrange for his body to be flown home.

The couple had decided to travel around south-east Asia, and local sources said it was easy to access drugs in Chiang Mai.

- Paul Melia and Andrew Drummond

Pictures: Andrew Chant/Boem Chiang Mai

Police re-arrest ‘The Ghost’ April 2 2008

Police re-arrest ‘The Ghost’ - April 2 2008

From Andrew Drummond
Bangkok
Wednesday April 2 08

A convicted British child-rapist was back behind bars in Thailand today after police revoked bail after angry protests by a child protection agency.

Maurice Praill, 77, nicknamed ‘The Ghost’ from Harold Hill, Essex, was sent to Nongplalai prison, Pattaya, after Sudarat Sereewat a member of the country’s National Child Protection Committee complained ‘on behalf of the children of Thailand’.

Praill had earlier boasted that a local policeman played the keyboards at his wedding to a 15-yr-old child bride in a ceremony blessed by Buddhist monks.PraillM04 Wedding 1

He will appear in court on April 7th on a charge of child sexual abuse with an eight year old boy where he is expected to ask for bail again.

Praill was convicted in 2001 and sentenced to 14 years in jail for the rape of two under-aged girls in Pattaya. But he never did time. He got bail to appeal against his conviction and when he lost his appeal in 2004, he was given bail again to appeal to Thailand’s Supreme Court.

He was arrested again last year together with three other foreigners and charged again with child sex abuse.  In this case it was alleged young girls were delivered to foreigners on the back of a motorcycle.  One of the alleged victims in this case was the daughter of Praill’s latest maid.

Praill was bailed. But the prosecution subsequently offered no evidence against him although an American was subsequently jailed for 16 years.

Then last month Praill was arrested for sexually abusing an eight year old boy. Again he was bailed, this time for 400,000 Thai baht (£6,411).

After he was released Sudarat Sereewat, also Secretary General of FACE (Fight Against Child Exploitation) protested to Region 2 Provincial Police, which covers the resort of Pattaya.

“If we can’t put this man behind bars to protect our children, who can we (have detained)?” she said.

Local newspapers in Pattaya have reported that Praill was arrested on allegations of child abuse even before 2001 but was released after paying local ‘fines’ at Pattaya Police station.

Shortly after his arrival in Thailand he went through a marriage ceremony to a 15-yr-old girl, the daughter of a previous maid. The wedding was blessed by monks and a Pattaya policeman played keyboards at the party claimed Praill, whose stepson Jon Goodman played soccer for Ireland, Crystal Palace and Wimbledon.

 Praill, said he was surprised himself that he got bail. Nicknamed the ‘Ghost’ by children who describe his appearance as scary, he said after his release: “It’s incredible. How can an alleged offender who has committed rape against two young girls on four separate occasions ever get bail for that? And how could he get bail again? It could not happen in the UK, but it happened in Thailand which is comforting for me.”

The British Government has spent hundreds of thousand of pounds on courses for Thai police, social workers, and court officials, on how to deal with child sex offenders.

Most courses have been preceded by receptions at the Ambassador’s mansion.