Monday, May 19, 2014

Monday, May 19, 2014

British Human Rights Activist Andy Hall who helped prepare a report on working conditions for immigrant labour at a Thai pineapple and fruit juice business in Prachuap Khiri Kan today surrendered to Thai police in Bang Na, Bangkok.

The occasion was more harmonious than a previous incident in which it is alleged that police tried to stitch him up with a confession. Andy Hall is being sued by the National Fruit Company for both criminal and civil libel seeking US$100 million damages. He was one of four members of a team who produced a scathing report for Finnwatch on the production facility.

Here follows a statement from Finnwatch
Finnwatch Researcher Andy Hall To Face Public Prosecutor on 18th June 2014 After Police Station Questioning Today

British migrant rights activist Andy Hall, who campaigns to improve conditions for migrant workers in Thailand, today met investigators at Bangna Police Station in Bangkok. 
Natural Fruit Company Ltd., a company based in Prachuap Khiri Khan Province of Thailand, began a series of civil and criminal prosecutions against Andy Hall in February 2013. Charges relate to his role in conducting interviews with migrants from Myanmar to assist Finnwatch to compile a report, Cheap Has a High Price. 
Fingerprinted for libel
This report, released in Jan 2013 and updated in Jan 2014, outlined poor labour conditions in Natural Fruit's factory, selling pineapple concentrate to Finnish supermarkets.  
Finnwatch researcher Andy Hall today voluntarily met with police investigators. Police were investigating Natural Fruit's third criminal charge against Andy Hall, criminal defamation, relating to an interview he gave in Myanmar to Aljazeera in early 2013.  
– His fingerprints were taken and he was questioned for almost four hours. Andy Hall reported that the police treated him fairly and transparently. He was provided free of charge a proper translator, certified by Thailand's Ministry of Justice, and was able to leave after the hearing was over, said Finnwatch Executive Director Sonja Vartiala.  
Last time Andy Hall visited Bangna Police Station on 28th September 2013, an officer attempted to get Hall to sign a Thai language confession accepting guilt to all accusations laid against him and translation offered was poor. Hall refused to sign the document, requested a copy and left the station.  
During today's appearance at the police station, concerning information was provided to Andy Hall that the lawyer for Natural Fruit recently contacted to the independent translator assigned to assist Hall by the Ministry if Justice.  
Finnwatch sees all legal actions against Andy Hall as an attack against a human rights defender and his freedom of expression. 

Legal action against Andy Hall has raised international criticism and several NGOs and global trade union federations have condemned these legal actions. UN Special Rapporteurs have asked Thailand to clarify how it ensures judicial processes in the country do not result in attempts to harass human rights defender's work.  
– Andy Hall has told us that he will voluntary take part to all judicial hearings. He has done nothing wrong and hopes that this legal process will shed only further light on systematic labour rights abuses in Thai exporting industries, says Vartiala.  
Andy Hall is now scheduled to meet Thailand's public prosecutor on 18th June 2014 when he will know whether the case against him will go to court or be dropped.  
Together Natural Fruit has raised four charges personally against Andy Hall. Two criminal charges relate to defamation and breach of the computer crimes act and are pending summons delivery in the criminal court. A third charge relates to civil defamation. The case discussed today in Bangna Police station was the latest and fourth charge against him, also of criminal defamation.  
If found guilty of criminal charges laid against him, Andy Hall could face together seven years in prison per count. Natural Fruit are also claiming seven million euros in damages from Andy Hall in the civil case against him. 

Serious problems in Natural Fruit's labour conditions have been highlighted in several other reports and research as well as the Finnwatch report, to which Andy Hall assisted. According to Finnwatch's information, Thai authorities have not raised any legal actions against Natural Fruit. 


  1. The Pinneap[le Juice Industry is gigantic, the region of Prachuap produces Pineaples 11 month of the year, imagine how much chemicals are needed to maintain this year after year, I call these juices "pesticide juices" fruits absorb most water from the heavily contaminated soil where these Pineaples are cultivated. I do not know how workers would be also in exposure danger...I remember that Tipco alone produced 800.000 tons of the juice a month. Nothing that is so mass produced can be any good for health. I would like to see a chemical residues test on these fruit juices... I am almost sure it would show higher than allowed limits for certain phosphat based defensives, the worse ones... About the prosecution it will never happen, it is a lost case for the Juice producers. There are undeniable facts and evidence, it would be hypocritical to pursue such lie by the fruit company accusers.