Friday, January 15, 2016

Friday, January 15, 2016

New attacks against Thailand suggesting skullduggery behind the investigation into the death of that 26-year-old Luke Miller, whose body was found last week in a swimming pool on the island of Koh Tao, have been launched on Facebook as Luke’s holiday pals landed at Heathrow today.

Just 24 hours after Laura Witheridge the sister of Hannah Witheridge,  who was raped then murdered with David Miller on the island last year, was forced to withdraw an emotional ‘Thailand is not beautiful’ attack,  Luke’s sister Maria and Nichola Gissing, one of his holiday companions, recorded clearly bitter criticisms of the popular holiday destination.

Luke’s death has also drawn attention to a  ‘pack attack’ in the same beach bar ‘The Sunset Bar’ where Briton Luke Miller died last week in which its claimed bar staff joined forces to beat a young backpacker ‘like a dog with a piece of meat.'

The attacks fall short of accusing the locals on Koh Tao directly of the murder of Luke Miller. Maria refers only to injustice. But murder claims have been bandied about privately and Nichola and James Gissing have returned to Britain with pictures they secretly took of Luke’s body on the Thai mainland.

Those pictures, it is alleged, show that the injuries are different to those described by police, who said Miller could have scratched his face on barbed wire while climbing up a DJ booth to dive into the pool.

Sunset Bar

Thai Police closed their investigation announcing that he drowned and may have been intoxicated. There was nothing signaling a murder, they said.

Luke’s mother went on BBC TV South East to suggest there were shortfalls in the Thai investigation.
Nichola with Luke (Facebook)

Nichola Gissing who was on holiday with her brother James and Luke, all from the Isle of Wight, today posted on the new Facebook site 'Luke's Legacy'

“They hate us over there. Land of Smiles, my ass. Land of snakes and murderers, Mafia, rapists and corruption.”

She was joined by Luke’s sister Maria who said: “This won't be swept under the carpet . . . guaranteed. 
“If anything good is to come out of this crazy surreal nightmare then warning others and getting justice should be the way forward.  
“That island needs all the bad publicity it can get. This can't happen again. I wouldn't wish this heartbreak on anyone. Xxxxx”
James and Nichola fled to the mainland after Miller’s body was transferred for examination in the provincial capital Surat Thani. Police had initially seized their passports and mobile phones. They went into the hospital and took pictures when other people’s backs were turned.
Davud Miller and Hannah Witheridge

They boarded a London bound flight last night complaining the British Embassy was of little use. telling friends they were scared and had been followed. Before leaving that had stayed in private accommodation.

Nichola has also called for support for Zaw Lin and Waiu Phyo the two Burmese sentenced for the murders of Hannah Witheridge and David Miller.

"This page is also to out the real killers of Hannah and David and any other innocent person murdered in Koh Tao, the ones we know of and the ones that have never come to light. To save Wai Phyo and Zaw Lin the two Burmese men that have been sentenced to death for these murders, two innocent men who were tortured by Koh Tao police to admit to murders they did not commit," she wrote

When I called the ‘Sunset Bar’ the Thai who answered the phone but did not give his name said: “It was an accident. Foreigners like to go wild at parties. He probably climbed onto the DJ booth and hurt himself. We have pictures. You can come here any time and see for yourself. We have nothing to hide.”

He said there was no CCTV as it had been down for about three months. This appears to contradict a police claim that here is CCTV evidence. 

The line cut and I asked a Thai colleague to call.  She reported back that the man who took the call appeared to be a policeman. He said much the same. There were no secrets.  She was unable to connect again.

The conversations created more questions than answers. The only conclusion was that they supported the Thai police line.

In an emotional state Nichola also claimed on Facebook she was scared to go to the Embassy because ‘certain names, won’t mention right now, are being paid off.’

It is possible she might be confusing Embassy indifference and its policy of not interfering with the justice system of another country with some sort of corruption.

Much more specific is an account on the internet describing a pack attack by Thais on a single foreigner in the Sunset Bar on Sairee Beach, Koh Tao on Boxing Day.  

Pack attacks by groups of Thais on lone foreigners are not uncommon in Thailand. They usually occur in bar areas, and usually follow a small confrontation or argument, sometimes over a bill.

These attacks can be very vicious and often bottles or knives are used.

The story on a website called Planeless Travellers (linked below) has the following account. (edited) The fight appeared to have started after a trivial argument.

Davy - pic Herlinde Noppe
“Yesterday night my friend Davy got beaten up in ‘The Sunset Beach Bar’ on Koh Tao. What happened is unacceptable. 

‘The Sunset Beach Bar’ is one of the most popular places to party on Koh Tao. As always, what ended up to be a terrible night, had a pretty good start.
Ien, Davy, Yasmin and I and another friend are watching the fire acrobats in front of the bar on the beach, just like many other tourists. At some point, it’s not very late in the evening yet, about 11h-ish, Ien and Yasmin decide to go home, and I stay at the bar with Davy and his friend.  

 Two girls and one guy, all three of them bar staff, are hitting him. The guy is stomping him with his foot, shoes on, the girls do the same. 
“ At some point the staff announces through the microphone something about a free bucket and jumping in the pool. Together with some other people, Davy and his friend decide to jump in the pool. The party goes on for a while, and I am dancing with two Finish girls I’ve just met.  
The next thing I see is my friend Davy on the ground being pushed in my direction, his face full of blood. Two girls and one guy, all three of them bar staff, are hitting him. The guy is stomping him with his foot, shoes on, the girls do the same. Everything happened so fast. I try to stand in front of Davy because I was pretty sure they would not hit me. While Davy is behind me – not fighting back since the beginning, but just being a victim of their actions – they keep trying to get as close as possible to continue beating him up. 
A few tall male customers see what is happening and try to get the aggressive people away from Davy. I tell Davy and his friend: “We have to get out of here!” I try to take Davy’s hand to follow me and leave, but we can’t. The aggressive people keep coming to him like dogs that want a piece of meat. Luckily, the tall guys keep defending Davy, and one of them succeeds to take him out of the bar together with Davy’s friend. 
This all happened so quickly. I was – and still am – so shocked about this event. I could see it was not a fight with other tourists, but that it were people from the staff. 
Whatever my friend did, I was thinking at that moment, no one ever deserves to be beaten up like this. 
I talked to other customers afterwards, and they too were shocked by the severe cruel approach. It really looked like they wanted to kill my friend. Not just one push or one punch on the nose, but they were continuously hitting my poor friend who was sitting on the floor like a fetus, his hands on his head, trying to protect his face. 

 But what happened last night – the animal-like cruelty in which some people can hurt another human being – is something I have never seen happening in front of my eyes before. 
 Apparently, between when I saw them jumping in the pool and when I saw my friend with his face full of blood, they were asking about the free bucket they were promised. But they were told that they wouldn’t get it, and Davy began to argue that they should. Davy was angry and showed his fuck-you-finger to the bar lady. The next thing that happened was Davy being beaten up. 
I know these things happen all the time. I have seen some fights in my life: in movies, or in the corner of a bar between drunk people. But what happened last night – the animal-like cruelty in which some people can hurt another human being – is something I have never seen happening in front of my eyes before. 
Some people told us to let it go. They told us that the only thing that will happen if we go to the police, is that the rich bar owner will pay them to close the case. But we didn’t care. If everyone closes their eyes all the time to these kinds of events, nothing will ever change. If because of this some people will not go to this bar anymore, that would already be an achievement.” 

The matter according to the writer ‘Charlie’ was settled with just one of the attackers having to pay a 10,000 baht fine (about £200) at the local police station, which if the man was a member of the bar staff would have been settled by the bar.
Footnote Thai police have threatened to sue Laura Witheridge for her remarks, though quite where they did not say. She is not in Thailand and Thailand has no powers to see her extradition. The Courts of Justice issued the following statement: Laura initially edited her post. Then she deleted it. Now she has closed down her Facebook page.


People are in grief and angry. Some of their comments may be over the top. They can be forgiven for that. But people in Thailand know how deceitful the police are capable of being. They know how people are regularly set up. The term 'goat' as in scapegoat  is a common word in Thailand. The scenarios recounted on Koh Tao are uncannily similar to the experiences of the travellers in Alex Garland's 'The Beach' the film of which ironically led to a tourism explosion. A bunch of travellers thought they had found their paradise. but it had a major drawback. Mafia and death. The land never belonged to the travellers. Tt belonged to a fierce local mafia, who tolerated them, but punished those who broke their rules - terminally.

Planeless Travellers:
Luke’s Legacy


  1. I witness a mob of Thais assault a man in Jomtien at 7AM, April 13, 2013.
    A Russian man was causing a disturbance at the First Hotel on Soi 5. He was drunk and making a scene in front of the hotel. A policeman was standing by and many locals and hotel staff were watching with some taking video. A local clubbed him in the head wit a 2 meter piece of wood, fell in g the Russian. The Russian was out cold, face down and the police,an cuffed him. I thought the event was over, but the crowd of Thais began violently stomping on his skull and taking full soccer type kicked to his head. The policeman stood by and just watched when the Thai man with the wooden club took a full swing and cracked his skull. I'm pretty sure the Russian did not survive. The policeman did not arrest the killer or men that violently kicked his head. The Russian was knocked out cold, was cuffed and they murdered him...all on hotel cctv with many witnesses. This is Thailand!

    1. Correction:
      After checking my files, the above event occurred in 2012, not 2013.

    2. I took a video of the incident but turned off the recording when the policeman cuffed the Russian. I thought the incident was over, then the Policeman backed away and the mob attacked the guy. Have a clear screenshot of the guy and the wooden club.

    3. So, post it online then. Those who are unaware of Thailand behind the masks need to be enlightened.

  2. I lived on Koh Samui for ten years and I have seen many Things over the years which the Thai authorities would not want made public! The Thai people are generally scared to speak out against injustice for two reasons, one is the reaction of other Thai people and the other is the Thai authorities, who will not tolerate any criticism of their country or poeple in any shape or form even if it is justified! I have left Thailand now and feel like I can breath again after years of being told "you cannot say that in Thailand".As for the Thai police I know from personal experience they are worse than useless and want to be paid for everything they do and will blame anyone apart from Thai people because Thai people are perfect in every way! I am so happy to have left Thailand and when I look back I wonder why I decided to live there. If you are thinking of moving to Thailand please do you homework before you compromise your safety and your sanity!

  3. Any comment to make, Bob, on Kilgour Trout's account above?

  4. ...and that was you, as you say yourself, speculating about the outcome of an event 2 years ago. Did you post about it at the time?

  5. The British Embassey have a lot to answer for. Should they not be issuing notices to unsafe destinations?
    We all know how they have spent week after week on golf courses and never challenge the Thai authority when Brits are in trouble. They just pop up the world wide Consul answer. While we cannot comment on individual cases we are assisting the families of the person involved. Its all bullshit. We have a great life, a great posting and upsetting the Thais would jeopardise that so please f@@@ off and give us peace is what it should say

  6. "Davy was angry and showed his fuck-you-finger to the bar lady." Pretty dumb thing to do, especially in Thailand.

    1. Surprised he wasn't murdered aren't ypu?

    2. seen people badly hurt for less several times. Thai men in general are cowards and a toe to toe is a no go. They attack in groups and show no mercy. Thailand has over the years become to easy for youngsters to fall into its traps. Its not Spain

  7. I owned several successful, reputable businesses on Phuket, for many, many years. A few years ago several of my Thai employees, one with her Brit boyfriend and I were celebrating a b'day. The employee and her boyfriend left about a half hour before me. When I walked to my car I saw a crowd of Thai's attacking something in the ditch with rocks and boulders. I realized it was my staff and her friend curled up, bloody, getting bashed. When I started to intervene a policeman I knew pulled me back and said "K. ___ you don't want to get involved." I stupidly did anyway, lucky for me the Police that were there knew me and pulled the pack off long enough for me to get them in my car and to hospital. Their injuries were extensive and recovery took over a year. Due to safety concerns I had them flown to a hopital out of the country to recover. This after the police chief came to my house to tell me that I should not say anything, that they were "sh*t people, that they did not deserve to live, that I had complained too much to Bangkok (I had), etc.

    Their crime had been that on their way out the door the bouncer thought they didn't hold the door open for him long enough and that was disrepectful.

    Nothing that Ms Witheridge said was wrong or untruthful and there is of course no grounds for defamation. She is right, Thailand's beauty is only skin deep and Koh Tao specifically should be boycotted. What I saw that night was horrifying and no one deserves. I am sure Davy didn't deserve what he got and reasonably sure that Luke is not going to get the justice he deserves. My heart goes out to all of the victims and their families. But it is time tourists knew the real Thailand.

  8. Yes, there have been a few beaten to a pulp, always best to keep your fuck-you –finger in your pocket.