Wednesday, July 27, 2016

Wednesday, July 27, 2016
4
A FEW GOOD WOMEN


Naritsarawan Kaewnopparat
Thailand’s military is not traditionally good at handling the truth but then it does not need to be. 

The military were never punished for the Tak Bai massacre* or for the massacre at Krue Se Mosque*. The army of course is used more against the people rather than an enemy.

However, in the case of Private Wichian Puaksom, 26, the army paid out some US$200,000 compensation. Was that an admittance of serious crimes? Apparently not.

An officer and nine other soldiers were involved in the following brutal treatment of him in 2011.

They forced him:


“to strip Wichian down to his underwear and drag him over a rough concrete surface before repeatedly kicking and beating him for several hours. Soldiers then put salt in Wichian’s wounds to increase the pain. They wrapped his body with white cloth, bound his hands, read him funeral rites, and forced him to sit on ice. They then beat Wichian with bamboo rods, kicked him, and stomped on his chest and his head.”

Despite his death from his injuries four days later, on June 5 Sub-lieutenant Om and the other nine soldiers only received military disciplinary punishment of 30 or fewer days in detention, but were never charged for murder or other serious offences. 

There goes the Thai army again, falsely defending its honour.

Was Private Wichian the subject of a ‘Code Red’? This whole scenario is uncannily similar to the plot of the Hollywood film a ‘Few Good Men’ with Jack Nicholson, Demi Moore and Tom Cruise.



(above - don't expect this sort of exchange in a Thai court)


Wichian was attacked allegedly for ‘fleeing military training’. In the film ‘A Few Good Men’ Private William Santiago is the subject of an unofficial order ‘A Code Red’ to beat him into being a better US Marine.

In Thailand of course truth is of course stranger than fiction and in this case the officer in charge of the unit is not in the dock like Jack Nicholson playing the Marine Colonel. 

Instead Wichian’s courageous niece faces jail under Thailand’s Computer Crime Act, for having the balls to complain that the punishment was not sufficient.


So now we have the spectacle of seeing an Army Captain, the Commanding Officer of Wichian’s unit in the 151st Battalion of the 3rd Infantry Division going into the witness box to prosecute Naritsarawan Kaewnopparat for comments she made on her Facebook page.

Correction, well we won’t be able to see anything as Thailand’s laws prevent contemporaneous court reporting and even forbid journalists to take notes. We’ll just get the judgement.

Yes, you cannot make this up!


Links:

*The Tak Bai Massacre

*Kru’ Se Mosque

The following is a statement today issued by Human Rights Watch:

Thailand: Torture Victim’s Outspoken Niece Arrested
End Reprisals Against Families Seeking Justice

(New York, July 27, 2016) – Thai authorities should drop trumped-up criminal proceedings against a woman who has sought justice for her army conscript uncle, who was tortured to death by soldiers in 2011, Human Rights Watch said today. Naritsarawan Kaewnopparat, 25, faces up to five years in prison and a 100,000 baht (US$2,900) fine if found guilty of defamation and publicizing false information online under the Computer Crimes Act.

On the morning of July 26, 2016, police arrested Naritsarawan at her office at the Ministry of Human Security and Social Development in Bangkok. She was taken to the Muang Narathiwat police station and questioned about her Facebook page. The page details the case of her uncle, Pvt. Wichian Puaksom, 26, whom soldiers tortured to death at a military camp in Narathiwat province, and demands that those responsible be brought to justice. On July 27, the police released Naritsarawan on bail. The complaint against Naritsarawan was brought by an army captain who had been commanding officer of the unit found responsible for Wichian’s death.

“The Thai police’s efforts to intimidate and retaliate against the outspoken relative of a victim of rights abuse is no less than an endorsement of torture,” said Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “The government should immediately direct the police to drop the criminal cases against Naritsarawan and seek the prosecution of those responsible for her uncle’s death.”

An internal investigation by the 4th Army Region, responsible for Thailand’s southern provinces, found that soldiers severely tortured Private Wichian of the 151st Battalion of the 3rd Infantry Division on June 1, 2011. The report said that Sub. Lt. Om Malaihom, who had accused Wichian of fleeing military training, ordered at least nine soldiers to strip Wichian down to his underwear and drag him over a rough concrete surface before repeatedly kicking and beating him for several hours. Soldiers then put salt in Wichian’s wounds to increase the pain. They wrapped his body with white cloth, bound his hands, read him funeral rites, and forced him to sit on ice. They then beat Wichian with bamboo rods, kicked him, and stomped on his chest and his head. Wichian died from his injuries four days later, on June 5. Sub-lieutenant Om and the other nine soldiers received military disciplinary punishment of 30 or fewer days in detention, but were never charged for murder or other serious offences.



Private Wichian’s family sued the Ministry of Defense, the army, and the Prime Minister’s Office for malfeasance and was provided 7,000,000 baht (US$200,000) compensation in February 2014. In July 2015, the Office for Public Sector Anti-Corruption found Om and nine other soldiers guilty of malfeasance under article 157 of the penal code and article 30 of the military penal code.

In May 2016, Prime Minister Gen. Prayut Chan-ocha promised to make torture a criminal offense under Thai law and to fulfill Thailand’s obligations under the United Nations Convention against Torture. Under the convention, the Thai government is obligated to investigate and prosecute acts of torture and other ill-treatment committed by government officials. However, the Thai government has yet to prosecute successfully any security personnel for abuses. Thai authorities have also frequently retaliated against those reporting alleged human rights violations by filing lawsuits accusing critics of making false statements with the intent of damaging the officials’ reputation.

“It has always been risky to speak up on behalf of victims of military abuses in Thailand,” Adams said. “Now the government is using the full weight of its legal system against those urging justice.”

4 comments:

  1. A culture of torture, widely prevalent in Thailand most obviously by the military and the police, is not for the 21st century. Hence the authorities generally go for psychological torture, which ruins people's lives all the same, and hence they can come out with outrageous lies and confessions regarding, for example, the Burmese 2. Much respect to this woman for standing up for truth and justice. And shame, so much shame, on the murderous institutions of Thailand who disguise their criminality through uniforms and authority and through engaging in constant bullying and cowardly acts of fear and terror-based control. These people are bullies and cowards, a straight-up nothing zero without the gang behind them. The people who run Thailand, both nationally and provincially, and all the foreign criminals who thrive in its corruption, are the opposite of tough. They're weak, and they know it, they have nothing to offer a positive, informed and educated society and so they forcibly and selfishly insist that people live in an uninformed, negative and criminal society, full to the brim of lies and deceit, the one which suggests money hierarchy as its be all and end all. The one where boiler room Emperors drive around in gaudy motorcars with police escorts and bodyguards - these people have ruined thousands of lives, the police should be, dare I say, arresting them. Too much money. They're weak people,though, all of them, miserable lives always looking over their shoulder. Decent people, who live decent lives and respect humanity, do not require bodyguards. Lest we forget, there are 2 Burmese imprisoned for a hideous crime they quite clearly did not commit. Much respect Naritsarawan.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think all countries have skeletons in their closets by degree - Thailand's closet must be larger than Emelda Marcos' old closet over in Manila - where she kept about 10,000 pairs of shoes - in that sense neither the shoes, nor justice in Thailand see the klieg light of day..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's perhaps an Eminem line by degree. There but not here. I prefer one from Bowie's penultimate, for whoever on the army side that literally survives the eventual overthrow, and for the boiler room frauds who feel that their arrogance is untouchable... 'just remember duckies everybody gets got.'

      Delete
    2. 'You never give me your money, you only give me your funny paper.'

      Delete