Archive for the 'General News' Category

Brits in Thai island ‘drug rape’ pin their hopes on Scotland Yard

From Andrew Drummond, Koh Chang, Thailand

Link Evening Standard  The SUN

White Sands Beach, Koh Chang

White Sands Beach, Koh Chang

Scotland Yard confirmed today that they have conducted tests on a British couple who say they were subjected to a horrifying gang rape in Thailand and planned to co-operate with a Thai police investigation into the incident.

The couple who fled back to London feeling that Thai police were botching their own investigation have given video statements  and undergone extensive forensic analysis ,  at the hands of a Metropolitan police ‘Sapphire Project’ team.
the-havenThey are now receiving counseling at ‘The Haven’, the Met Police, Barts and NHS Sexual Offences Referral unit at the Royal London Hospital in Whitechapel – after a seemingly horrific ‘Clockwork Orange’ style attack on them on the Thai holiday Island of Koh Chang last month.
Known by the names ‘Richard’ and ‘Susan’ they claimed the rapes happened when they must have invited other fellow tourists, a girl and two men, they had met at a beach bar to their holiday bungalow to continue to drink and listen to music in their room.  The couple cannot actually recall inviting anyone back and say it would have been out of character.

clockwork_orange02

Susan, 31, said she recalled that the English girl requested she put on the song ‘It’s getting hot in here, so please take off your clothes’, by Nelly.  But she could not work her laptop anymore and must have passed out in the process of looking for it.
Both lost consciousness and Richard, 42, a company director, said he recalled briefly waking as he was being forcibly held against a bungalow window and made to watch his girlfriend, being raped by two men.
The couple claimed they slept for two days afterwards, occasionally waking up to splitting headaches.  When the headaches wore off both felt considerable discomfort both in their sexual organs and anal passages. “I had no strength or ability to resist or fight”.
When they went to the local hospital on Koh Chang, a doctor called police on their behalf. He said that the couple had symptoms of having been administered the drug Dormicon.
Dormicon is a generic of midzolam which has been used in the United States to give to prisoners on death row to relax them shortly before execution.  It’s also used as a pre-op drug in hospitals. It can affect people in different ways.
At Koh Chang’s International Clinic Dr. Roongtham Charentantanakul who counseled them said: “We have had other cases like this, but this is the first case that I have heard of where foreigners have given such a drug to other foreigners.
“These cases are very difficult to deal with.  These drugs have two main affects, one is hypnotic and the other is retrograde amnesia.  That means the victims can fully co-operate with their attackers and then afterwards forget all about it or only have partial recall. In one case, he said,  a woman was actually injected on a dance floor. She felt it something in her upper arm when it happened and looked around, but as she was a little bit drunk, she just carried on dancing.
“There are unscrupulous drug store owners in Thailand who will sell these sorts of drugs over the counter.
“But unless the couple are treated and tested immediately traces of the drugs disappear from the body within 12 hours.  In that case all the evidence police will get is that they actually co-operated.”
Susan however said today: “We have been told by Scotland Yard forensics officers that it is possible that they can find a trace of the drug, and of sexual assault.  We have both been given full tests and those have shown I have been assaulted, although because of the time frame some things have healed. We will have to wait for further tests of hair roots as they try and identify the drug’s make-up.”
Richard and Susan had just spent 11 months on a round the world and decided to spend the last week of a ‘truly wonderful experience’ chilling out on the beach at Koh Chang, an island just off Cambodia.

The popular Sabay Bar on Koh Chang

The popular Sabay Bar on Koh Chang

On November 18th they said they went to the popular ‘Sabay” beach and music bar on Haad Sai Kao (White Sands Beach) Koh Chang to watch a fire show and dance and listen to the band.
There they met three Frenchman and an English girl and spent much of the evening in their company.
When the bar closed the couple, the English girl, and two of the Frenchmen, went back to their bungalow at White Sands Garden situated up a hill in a rubber plantation. They were later joined by the third Frenchman. Shortly afterwards both Richard and Susan say they lost consciousness.

The couple's bungalow room at White Sands Garden

The couple's bungalow room at White Sands Garden

Said Richard: “The police acted as if they did not believe our story. They did not take any DNA evidence from the room, but it was clear the bed cover was heavily stained and there were marks on the window where my face had been pressed against it.
“I woke up in a foetal position outside our bungalow room. These men were laughing as they left. They boasted about what they had done. I believe the English girl was used to give us a feeling of re-assurance, and in fact we were targeted from the point we met this group.
“We left Thailand because we were unhappy with the investigation and we took the bedclothes with us. But it has always been my intention to go back and I have told the Embassy to tell the police I will.  What these people did was barbaric.”
From their own enquiries the couple has established details of two of the four people and have information about the third man.  One of them has since removed his ‘Facebook’ page, a second is the son of a wealthy businessman and is known for his martial arts. They believe they have found an internet photograph of the third man.
At the island’s police station Inspector Sibayot Chittiyakul said: “ We are taking this seriously, but we need witnesses.  The safety of tourists is important to us. But the couple have to understand we have procedures to follow and the first thing is to get their full statements.
“We have names and identities and are monitoring the case, one of whom has a Thai address. But we cannot make an arrest until the man completes his statement.”
The Thai owner of the White Sands Garden who asked not to be named said however the group all arrived back in the early hours on November 19th and seemed to be enjoying themselves. 
“The English man later apologized in the morning for all the noise. Foreigners like to party. That is all it seemed to us.”
A spokesman for Scotland Yard said: “We can confirm that an SCD2 Team (Special Crime Directorate 2 - Sapphire Project) from Kingston have been assisting the Thai authorities in reference to allegations of rape.” The spokesman added as it was a Thai investigation the matter would have to go through the appropriate channels.

Rape scene from 'A Clockwork Orange'

Rape scene from 'A Clockwork Orange'

 The 70s cult film ‘A Clockwork Orange’ directed by Stanley Kubrick and starring Malcolm McDowell is best remembered for a scene in which a gang of delinquents known as the ‘Droogs’ who get high on senseless violence  and rape a woman in front of her author husband. The anti-hero, Alex, is later treated with drugs by the state so that he suffers extreme nausea at the very thought of violence and sexual activity and is released into society where he becomes a victim.

The relevant FCO Travel Advisory

“There have been a number of incidents where tourists have had their drinks drugged (in both tourist areas and red light districts). You should be careful about taking drinks from strangers and be wary at clubs and parties, particularly in the Koh Samui area and at the Full Moon party on Phangan Island where incidences of date rape have been reported. A number of British nationals have suffered severe psychiatric problems because of drug use, in a small number of cases resulting in suicide.

We receive occasional reports of tourists who have been robbed after bringing visitors to their hotel rooms. In some cases their drinks were drugged. Ensure that your passport and wallet are secure at all times.

We continue to receive reports of sexual offences committed against foreign women and men. In 2007 our Consular staff were aware of a number of British nationals who were the victim of a serious sexual offence in Thailand. In January 2006, three British women were raped in separate incidents in Thailand, including one who was murdered.

Female travellers in particular should maintain a high state of personal awareness during their time in Thailand. Be aware that alcohol and drugs can lead to you being less alert, less in control and less aware of your environment. If you are going to drink, know your limit. Remember that drinks served in bars overseas are often stronger than those in the UK. Reports of sexual assaults against women have become particularly prevalent in the Koh Samui archipelago. Women travellers are, therefore, advised to take particular care over their personal security whilst staying in this area. For more guidance about this see our Rape and sexual assault overseas page.

You should report any incidents of crime to the Thai police before leaving the country.

Fisherman jailed for murder of British yachtsman - Thailand

 

Link to Sky News today  Sunday Mirror

Background Links: The Times, Daily Mail
From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, Saturday November 28 2009

Pictures: Andrew Chant

lindarobertsonmalcolmboat3

Two young Burmese fishermen have been sentenced to 25 years in prison each for the murder of 64-yr-old British yachtsman Malcolm Robertson off the coast of Thailand earlier this year.

At statement from the British Embassy in Bangkok today confirmed that Eksian Warapon, 19, and a shipmate known only as Aow, 18, were sentenced at Satun Provincial court earlier in the week.

A third Burmese, a juvenile known as Ko, aged 17, was sentenced to be held in custody until he reaches the age of 24, said Daniel Painter, Second Secretary at the British Embassy in Bangkok.

The two elder Burmese were initially sentenced to fifty years but their sentence was cut in half because they pleaded guilty and were remorseful.

The Burmese had been stranded on a small island off  Koh Adang in the Tarutao National Marine Park off the south coast of Thailand in March this year after jumping ship from a Thai fishing boat when Malcolm Robertson sailed in and moored offshore.

They were initially referred to as pirates but later it became clear that the young Burmese had been sold as slave labour to a Thai fishing fleet and had been in and out of immigration detention centres in Thailand.

 Before the attack they had spent eight months and sea without being allowed ashore with their Thai colleagues. They swum to the island and hopefully freedom.

But the island had no food and very little water.

Aow and Eksian (right)

Aow and Eksian (right)

Eksian Warapon, 19, told the court that all three were starving when the Robertson’s yacht ‘Mr. Bean’ anchored offshore,

“The boat was our only way of escape. We did not want to harm anyone but the foreigner put up a fight,” said Eksian..

They had swum to the boat and climbed aboard but were surprised by Mr.Robertson who started shouting at them.

Eksian admitted to being the person who bludgeoned Mr. Robertson with a hammer he had found on the 44 ft yacht, after the others tied up Linda Robertson, 57, naked in a cabin.

Later Mrs. Robertson, who with her husband owned a chain of cafes in Sussex,  made a courageous escape by freeing herself, weighing anchor and sailing away while her captors were mucking trying to get Mr. Bean’s ‘troublesome’  dingy to work.

The three men had agreed to leave the boat and had packed a dinghy with stolen property.including computers, mobile phones,

She said afterwards “But they had only got thirty yards when the engine began to splutter as I knew it would,

Linda Robertson in 'Mr. Bean's' dinghy

Linda Robertson in 'Mr. Bean's' dinghy

“They turned and started coming back, so I rushed to pull up the anchor, which was quite easy, because they had only let out thirty yards.  Then I put the boat into full throttle and headed out to see leaving them behind. 

“Then I saw them head to shore and I knew my ordeal was over and I was safe. I cannot believe I survived.”
Linda Robertson said today at her home St. Leonards, Sussex: “The juvenile showed a lot of remorse so I think his light sentence is justified. I am happy with the verdict. I am relieved they did not get the death penalty. Twenty five years in a Thai jail will be hell on earth. I would not wish any more on them. It’s another step towards getting over Malcolm’s death”..

A formal inquest will be held Sussex next month.

British couple subjected to vile ‘Clockwork Orange’ style sex attack - Thailand

Link to DailyMail Link New York Daily News
By Andrew Drummond
Last updated at 12:38 AM on 28th November 2009
A British couple have become victims of a horrendous Clockwork Orange-style sex attack ordeal while on holiday in Thailand.

The professional couple had chosen the Thai holiday island of Koh Chang to round off a memorable one-year sabbatical from their jobs touring the world.

But last night, the couple, one a government employee, the other a businessman, fled Thailand after they were subjected to a night of terror in which they say they were  drugged and raped by a gang they suspect preys on foreign tourists.

The couple did not wish to be fully identified. But the man, Richard, 42, remembers being forced to watch as his wife Susan, 31, was sexually assaulted by two men.

For the next two days, the couple lay almost motionless in their holiday bungalow as gradually their memories returned.

Koh Chang

Koh Chang

They called the police, but when nobody went to see them, they went to a local hospital to be examined by doctors.

Richard said: ‘The doctor there examined us and listened to our story and seemed to know what had happened straight away.

‘He told us we were showing all the symptoms of having been given the drug Dormicum – a date rape drug.  I do not know the drug, but it seemed of no surprise to the doctor.

‘When I asked the doctor if he could check for any traces, he said no, it would have been cleared out of our systems by now.’

They contacted the police, who they say showed scant  interest and did little in the way of investigation.

They also contacted British authorities, but say the British representative on the island who came to see them was not interested either.

Last night, they were on their way back to Britain, with little prospect of anything being done.  But they wanted to make others aware of the dangers of making contact with strangers in such places.

Richard said: ‘I know many people are not going to believe this and say that we must have been taking drink or drugs through choice. But nothing could be further from the truth.’

Susan said the night of their ordeal began with a pleasant drink at a beach bar, where they met an Englishwoman and some Frenchmen. They stayed in their company at the bar, although at one point she and her partner left for a short time, returning to join them. It was at that point, she believes, the drinks were spiked.

Clockwork Orange

Clockwork Orange

Things became a bit hazy. And then one of the Frenchmen lifted me up and carried me out of the bar.  In a normal situation I would not let anybody do such a thing.  It was bizarre.’

The group all went back to the couple’s bungalow.

‘Then things got hazier and hazier,’ she said.

‘Everything was a blur.’

Richard said he could vaguely remember being outside the bungalow and watching through a window as  Susan was assaulted by the men.

‘The next thing it was light and I was lying on the balcony in a foetal position and the Frenchman were standing above me looking down and laughing and saying what they had done to Susan.’

He realised that at some point he too had been sexually attacked.

The couple said that when they were able to complain to police ‘they did not seem very interested’.

After contacting the British Embassy they were visited by a consular representative, a local Thai woman, who told them the police would not take the case seriously.

‘We have been contacted by the police who have asked us what we are going to do,’ said Richard.

‘We do not want to let the matter drop. But we must get home to our families.’

A Thai Police spokesman strenuously denied they were not taking the couple’s complaint seriously and said an investigation was under way. 

A British Embassy spokesman said: ‘The consular team in Bangkok have been in touch throughout to give help and advice to the British nationals involved and are urgently following up with the Thai police.

‘A member of staff from our consulate in Pattaya visited the British nationals within the first day of the embassy being contacted  to provide face-to-face assistance. Our consular staff in London have also been in touch with the family members in the UK.’

Seeing me, seeing you! Foreign film crews in Pattaya

This is a blog only

The inevitable has happened. Well I guess it had to sometime.

The resort of Pattaya has always been an attraction to foreign film crews. They have to be sneaky. It’s a dangerous occupation down there, and as I think I mentioned before, pointing a camera in a wrong direction, particularly at a foreigner in a sex bar, can result in a severe injury with a telescopic lens.
But that does not stop producers insisting that, thirty seconds of scantily clad, nay even naked, girls in a go-go bar, can’t do any harm to the ratings.
To establish Thailand in their films, producer-directors used to use The Temple of the Emerald Bhudda. Now it seems a bit of totty helps too.
They are everywhere and they have now discovered that it is best not to look like a camera crew but to look like tourists.
Some producers can carry it off. Some cannot.  What has happened now is that one foreign television crew filming in Pattaya has filmed another film crew who have been filming in a go-go bar.
Not intentionally of course. They did not know the young couple in question was a film crew.

Gavin Hill and Dean Palmer of Vera Productions in happier days

Gavin Hill and Dean Palmer of Vera Productions in happier days

Stand up Gavin Hill, producer of ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’.  I mention this now because the man you caught on camera was one ’Olly Lambert’ producer and the director of a ‘Cutting Edge’ programme on British television last night ‘Confessions of a Traffic Warden” .  Now there’s a whipping boy if ever there was one, the traffic warden, that is, not Olly.

Olly and his ‘girlfriend’ were caught secretly filming in a place called  ’BabyDolls A-Go-Go’ in’ Pattaya by the owner who confiscated their gear, which must have been above the value of a US$300 Panasonic.
Olly was outraged but admitted: ”Well, I might have accidentally got shots of girls with their knickers off’.
When the charming, slightly sensitive and definitely indiscreet Howard Miller (He just can’t stop defending himself on the internet) Group Leader of Pattaya Tourist Police Assistants was called in to mediate, Olly Lambert came up with a strange tale.
He was looking for a girl, he said. A friend of his had recently died in the UK and had left something for her in his will.
“What - and film her naked first?  Was he looking for a birthmark or special tattoo?

We can show you to the door

We can show you to the door

Of course, Olly may have a tale to tell. From what I read on the internet Olly seems to have some awards, but awards in TV are perhaps as numerous as available girls in Pattaya.
He had to wait a day for his camera and was an unhappy bunny: “This place (Pattaya) is advertised all over the world as a sex tourist haven, but it is not okay to show it!” he complained indignantly.

I think Olly may have betrayed his bottom line there if you pardon the pun.

 But he has a point I suppose.  Pretty much all of the go-go bars in Pattaya have their own websites promoting their girls etc.  And if you really don’t care,  you can even have a birthday party there and get a picture taken looking exceedingly silly. There are a few up on the Babydolls website

We have a jacuzzi too!

We have a jacuzzi too!

These pictures will inevitably go up on the internet and it won’t be the first time a ‘wife left behind’ has found out what her her husband has been up to.

Now, before I sound totally hyprocritical, some years ago I did the Thai investigation for a programme called, rather unoriginally, ‘The Sex Slave Trade’ which was networked in the UK, and sold on to Australia and New Zealand.

Actually the victims of this trade were not from Soi Cowboy or Soi Thaniya. But the producer/director insisted on secret filming in these area from a blacked out van.

This was not without its comic moments.  First of all in Soi Thaniya the ‘reporter’ was instructed to walk slowly down the street casually talking to the girls outside each establishment.

sex-slave-trade-c4He could not speak Thai.  Few of the girls spoke English, but many spoke Japanese. And not one single one of them would give him a passing glance, let alone open up a dialogue or let him into her bar.

Then came Soi Cowboy. This meant actually driving up the Soi again as all the food vendors had to move their stalls to make away.

We were going far slowler than walking speed, which attracted the attention of the Soi Bobby who kept banging on the sides of the van (above). We of course refused to open the doors and sped off into Soi 23.  I made my escape and managed to get back to have a late drink at ‘Moonshine’ with amiable cricketer Aussie Steve. Like Gavin, who parted company with Dean Palmer, the Executive producer of  ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ I also complained about ‘The Sex Slave Trade’.

Its all here somewhere.

Finally if you want to see Olly defending himself, it’s all here on Episode 5 Part 1 of ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’

Gratuitous pictures: Babydoll.com

British woman ‘raped’ in Thai beach resort

British woman raped in Thailand – two men held

Link to Daily Mail

From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, Monday November 17

A British tourist claimed last night that she was dragged off the street by two men in front of Thai police and then taken to a hotel where she was raped and then robbed of her belongings.

The woman, aged 25, said the attack happened early Saturday morning in the Thai resort of Pattaya, twenty metres from a police box. The attack happened after she had been separated from friends. The abduction allegedly took place in Pattaya’s Walking Street.

She said she was unable to resist the two men who after raping her then left taking her Natwest bank and credit cards and 60 pounds in cash and a bracelet worth 100 pounds. Nobody came to her help.

The attack was kept secret at her request but last night police in Pattaya charged two men with rape and theft. They were named as Krajon Senkam, 29, and Surasak Kovekasan, 20, who were described as local ‘maeng da’ – a Thai expression , literally translating as cockroaches, describing men who live off the earnings of local prostitutes.

Police Colonel Wanlop Kangtharatit said the men were arrested quickly as they were known in the area.

 

 

Kidnapped priest wore down his captors with good humour

“When you go we will be free at last too!” they said after month long ordeal with troublesome priest

From Andrew Drummond, Manila, Friday, 13 2009

sinnott03Resilient Irish priest Father Michael Sinnott wore down his captors with words of kindness and prayers.

After ten days they gave up their political speeches threw their hands in the air and said: “If you go now we will be free too. We want you to go!”
Instead of a fit young captive who needed little attention they had found themselves nurses to a genial old man who in other circumstances could have been their friend, he said.

Faced with the priest’s refusal to believe in their cause and nonplussed with his gentle manner,  they ended up being his caretakers,  and praying themselves that no harm would come to the 79-year-old Irish Columban missionary.
The kidnap by a break-away faction of the Moro Islamic National Front in the Southern Philippines ended with his armed guards almost begging the authorities to take Father Sinnott back.
“ They had enough. They all wanted to go home too,” Father Sinnott told the Irish Daily Mail today (Friday) in Manila, “ I guess they had their own families to look after.
“We had started off at loggerheads.  They insisted they were freedom fighters and they were original indigenous people, known as Lumad, from Mindanao. They wanted their land back and a state with a constitution which would be the Koran.
“Well, I was having nothing of that blarney. I told them that most of Mindanao was now Christian. And in any case the original indigenous people were neither Christian nor Muslim. Actually Christianity came 200 years to the Philippines after Islam  but the majority are now Catholics.
“Really what they really wanted was $2million in ransom.  But it did not take them long to give up on that idea.
“For the first week ago there was little love lost.  They prayed their way and I prayed mine, staring up to the heavens flat on my back in a hammock as three times a day they faced Mecca.  But by the second week we were all praying for each other.
“Forget about the politics, or their crime.  These were normal people with families with the same aspirations as anyone. We got to know each other quite well.  They were very kind. Beside they may have had trouble on their hands.  I was not troublesome.  But I took a lot of looking after and they were worried for my health. 
“In the end I think they accepted that kidnap was forbidden by the Koran, and they were told that I believe by leaders of the real MILF.  But they argued that they had no other way to get funding.
Father Mick’s captivity came to an end on Thursday after representatives of the real Moro Islamic National Front ordered the breakaway group, to hand him back to the authorities.   No ransom was paid, but a small gratuity is believed to have given to the small group, as a face saving gesture.  It is not thought to have been over $5000.
It was on October 11th Father Sinnott was taking his daily exercise shirtless outside the Columban Mission in Pagadian, southern Mindanao after supper when he heard the sound of rushing feet behind him on the driveway. He was grabbed by three men and a fourth came to face him with a pistol.
The next minute he was bundled into a pick-up truck, known locally as a multi-cab, covered with a blanket and taken down to the shore.
“I know people associate the Southern Philippines with kidnap but I never thought in a million years anyone would come to the Columban Mission and actually do it.
“They put me in a boat and covered me up. Then took me to another and bigger and faster boat and transferred me and put me on the floor of the boat.  They  handled me roughly and blindfolded me but I could still see which side of the boats the lights were on, so I knew in which general direction we were going and it certainly was not in the direction they were telling me.
“When we put ashore again I had to walk with them for about one and a half hours. It was through stagnant muddy swamp water and we were guided by torchlight.
“When we stopped it was about 6am and getting light.  The number of guards had risen now from four to about 8 or 9.  I was stuck on a dry mound in the swamp about one metre by three metres.
“Hammocks were put up and I clambered in mine. If I got out one side I would end up in the swamp. On my other side was the guards’ hammock.
“We did not see eye to eye for the first few days. But I took things as they came. They argued about their cause, giving political sermons every day.  I was not having any of it but I guess I was good natured about it and they were nice people and eventually stopped and they treated me oh so very well.
“I certainly got the feeling they thought they had got the wrong guy.  I’m 79 years old and need taking care of and that’s just what they did.
sinnott-irish-daily-mail“Every little thing from helping me fasten my shoes to getting in and out of the hammock, and even moving in my hammock into a comfortable position, which is not so easy for an old man.
“They sent out men to get the provisions and brought for me things like bread and sandwich spread, which together with some of their rice was my daily intake. They also brought mosquito spray which made the swamp tolerable.  Who has ever heard of terrorists supplying mosquito spray and sandwich spread? 
Father Sinnott had last year been in hospital for a heart operation.
“When I told them I did not have my heart medicine, the medicine arrived at the end of ten days, but I had no trouble in the meantime.
“I even saw their shopping bags which showed they had done their shopping in Cotabato, so I had roughly guessed my location correctly.
“By the end of ten days they had clearly had enough themselves.  There was myself and two guards on one mound. Then on another mound a few yards away were another two guards, and a third dry mound was the cooking mound with another three guards.
“The only exercise I got was to jump up and down beside my hammock.  The boredom was the worst thing;  ten days stuck in a hammock or standing or sitting on a very small dry piece of land.
“I knew my guards by their first names, or nicknames.  There was Keekaye, who had five sons and two daughters. But he wished they he had seven sons so they could all be freedom fighters.
“There was Norking, who was just eighteen. He said he would rather fight by the power of a ballpoint pen than a gun. Then there were others called Alex, Jango, Max and Terry.
“In the end they were all on my side and wishing I would go soon.  Then on the 11th day I was moved.
“I thought I was moving to freedom. Because by now I was pretty sure I was going to be released.
“At no time apart from at the very beginning when I was roughly treated did I think any harm would come to me.  I believe in the power of prayer.  I could feel the power of the prayers from people in the Philippines and from back home at the Church of the Assumption in Clonard (Wexford).
“And of course, I was praying myself but I did not find prayers easy.
“When they moved me they took me on another boat ride about eight hours. Again I was in the bottom of the boat.  This time they marched me into a jungle area, but I know it was not far from civilization, because often during the day we could hear the sound of people in the jungle cutting away.
“One one occasion they got close, so we had to move further away.  But in the jungle life was better. I had a hammock and a tarpaulin, which would protect me from the rain, providing the rain came straight down, which it does not always do.
“They also cut me out a piece of the jungle as an exercise yard.  Even before the beginning of November I was sure I was going to be released.  But there were a couple of false alarms. I thought I was going to be released on November 4th but that attempt was abandoned because I gather the sea was too rough.

Welcome home shrine for Father Mick in Manila

Welcome home shrine for Father Mick in Manila

“I just had to continue the same routine until my release. Up at dawn. Breakfast followed by toiletries. Back to the hammock for prayers. Then onto a wooden log bench, maybe to chat with my captors, as I knew the local dialect.   Then in the afternoon back to the hammock to do a few decades of the Rosary.  There was nothing to read. No radio. We all just wanted to go home.
“When eventually my release came after being taken eight hours by boat to Zamboanga I was surprised at all the attention I received.  I knew lots of people were involved in the negotiations for my release, my fellow fathers, the Philippines Red Cross, the Government and Army, and the MILF themselves, not forgetting all those who prayed from me. I want to thank them all.  God Bless you.”
Father Michael, or Father Mick, as he is known, received a special welcome back home in the Philippines capital of Manila.

Father Mick (right) with Father Pat O'Donaghue in Manila

Father Mick (right) with Father Pat O'Donaghue in Manila

 At the Columban Centre in Ermita, Father Pat Don O’Donaghue, who flew to the southern Philippines to assist in the rescue said: “ Father Mick is dearly loved here.  He looks after over 60 disabled kids in the mission in Pagadian and is a leading member of the local inter-faith forum.
So while he was away not only were prayers being said in the Catholic and Christian churches worldwide, but prayers were being said in the local Catholic churches, the local Mosque and prayers were being said by the local tribal people.
“He is a remarkable and well-loved man.  He was my tutor in fact he has been the tutor to most of the Columban fathers in the Philippines”.

Short Q & A with Press Gazette for November 2009 issue

press-gazette-interview1

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

.

The BBC and the Gulf of Tonkin

This is a blog only
Is Burma softening its stance? The BBC is currently posing this question on its website in a fairly lengthy piece by my Bangkok colleague Alistair Leathead.
The article quotes Derek Tonkin, former British Ambassador to Bangkok  turned Burma watcher as saying: “Given the impasse of the last 20 years, what has happened in the last three months gives us the hope there will be some movement”.
The developments were that Senator Jim Webb was allowed to see Aung San Suu Kyi and also met with Than Shwe and who then reported back apparently to Obama that sanctions were not working.
Another reason was apparently a switch in US Foreign Policy to ‘pragmatic engagement’ but I am not sure if I see any change there. The US I believe has always considered itself to be pragmatically engaged everywhere, except the ‘Axis of Evil’.
But more recently Americans have been more vocal about Burma, hence the last Johnny Rambo film, fictionally and dramatically put on celluloid the very real brutality against its citizens. So brutal perhaps that many people may not believe that the situation is actually worse.
Derek Tonkin tells Alistair: “The generals are looking for international recognition for the 2010 election. They are trying to co-opt Aung San Suu Kyi and her National League for Democracy to take part in the elections without any constitutional change.
“We are still waiting for a really significant movement, but I could see Aung San Suu Kyi being released before the election if they could secure an understanding.”


I do not share Derek Tonkin’s muted enthusiasm.  You could say there is a little gulf between us.  In any case Derek Tonkin, reading between the lines, is quite cautious.  But why would Aung San Suu Kyi come to an understanding about a forthcoming election which has been widely discredited a long time in advance  with fairly firm evidence it is being rigged?
And we already know what happens when the junta lose an election.

The United Nations appeared to accomplished nothing. The Press briefings for journalists after the latest ‘rapporteur’ came out of Rangoon were not even worth attending.  Of course the U.S. of A probably has more clout than the U.N. Aung San Suu Kyi may be released, but the moment they smell trouble the junta will have her back under lock and key in  jiffy.

 

With the Karen National Liberation Army Eastern Burma 1987

With the Karen National Liberation Army Eastern Burma 1987

I have been watching Burma for nearly 25  years making films for the BBC (Burma’s Forgotten War) with the Karen and (Lord of the Golden Triangle) with ‘opium warlord’ Khun Sa and the Shan State Army (of Mong Tai Army) for ITV and also reporting for newspapers.

I have met and interviewed Aung San Suu Kyi, was in Rangoon for the 1988 uprising for the ‘Observer’ and later again in Burma for the last ‘election’.  All my trips to Burma have of course been illegal and when I was working on a BBC commission I was welcomed into villages in the middle of nowhere like a liberating general. Our trip appeared to give them some sort of hope.
I did not think then that the situation would be the same, if not worse, 20 years later.
The Burma’s military would have us believe they are benignly looking after their people. Evidence is that they are daily engaged in the slaughter, rape and torture of innocent civilians.
Much of this is monitored by the excellent ‘Free Burma Rangers’ who penetrate deeply into Burma offering medical and other aid.
The fact is that Britain, and the world has let down Burma. There will be no liberating army. Singapore and China openly supply the regimes weapons. Britain washed its hand of  Burma’s minorities, with whom it ruled Burma, in the Panglong Agreement.
 I even have a ‘friend ‘ who is investing in a tourist boat service near Pagan.  He does not get it. And if I can’t persuade him, then I am not about to persuade any world leaders.  They do what is expedient to themselves.
I am no apologist for the British Empire. But Britain did at least leave Burma with a structure, a justice system, and education system, and a functioning civil service, and did the same wherever its soldiers went…except perhaps Afghanistan!

Young Drummond with Khun Sa 1989

Young Drummond with Khun Sa 1989

The Burma’s junta has demonstrated how they can turn all those safeguards for democracy into weapons against the people.
And the British Empire has merely been replaced by the United States as the world policeman, but its agenda has been much more homeland security and oil, and I am not sure Obama has made such drastic changes in its stance towards Burma.
The fact is in Asia there are few bad guys.  At least few guys are regarded as such in history. In Britain we relish in our mad, stupid, and often ruthless Kings. We squeal with delight when we catch out MPs fiddling with their expenses. If the London Sun were to have free reign to publish in Bangkok every day its most oft used  headline might be ‘Liar. Lair Pants on Fire!’

In Asia it’s different. It’s a ‘face’ thing.  Thai history for example seems to have nothing but heroes. But we have all heard the expression ‘Life is cheap here’.
In Europe and the west we have Hitler as our ogre.  In Cambodia I suppose we have Pol Pot, Saloth Sar and his cronies.  But do we really?   The trials of the Khmer Rouge have been decades in the coming and have turned out all to be rather a damp squib.  There are not many people outside Cambodia who can remember the names of the lesser Khmer Rouge ‘war criminals’ on trial in Phnom Penh.  Ask yourself?  Moreover did not the west in fact indirectly support the Khmer Rouge when the communist Cambodian government was backed by Vietnam?

 And then there are the atrocities committed under the rule of Chairman Mao?

On a smaller scale perhaps Thailand’s ‘War on Drugs’ has left little stigma on its architect Thaksin Shinawatra. In fact it was widely supported even though of the some 2,500 mostly ‘killed injudicially’ ( murdered)  many were totally innocent and there were no ‘big boys’.

And in Thailand a petty foreign thief is going to serve more time than a politician corruptedly pocketing public money.

And while Thai Prime Minister Abhisit Vejjajiva has called for the release of Aung San Suu Kyi, Thailand has many commercial interests there. That is why General Chavalit Yongchaiyudh former Prime Minister who is now making a new bid for the spotlight can say: “I am, if you will, a super-prime minister. It’s not an exaggeration. The relations I’ve built with the neighbours are immense, spanning many years. It’s not just a partnership. We’re one family. With the Burmese leaders, we’re practically brothers.”

In both Burma and Cambodia we have to consider Chavalit’s self interests and of course those of Thaksin Shinawatra.

 The Japanese atrocities in World War 11 have never really been accepted back home and now 60 years on the Japanese are already taking a lead in creating a new ‘Greater Asia Prosperity Sphere’, though this now thankfully without the shouts of ‘Banzai’.

Thai camerman begs Thaksin Shinawatra to answer why his mother and father were gunned down by police in his 'War on Drugs'

Thai camerman begs Thaksin Shinawatra to answer why his mother and father were gunned down by police in his 'War on Drugs'

So will the Generals in Burma ever be called to account for the genocide within their own country? Probably not.  There have been so many of them, nobody has been there long enough to specifically be labelled Burma’s ogre, after Ne Win. 
What will happen to Burma? I guess we will all do what’s expedient at the time.
But personally, I cannot exercise pragmatism when it comes to Burma’s military rulers. Anyone who has been amongst the victims of Burmese military justice may have the same problem.

British broadcasting ‘watchdog’ rejects complaint about ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ UPDATED

Has Ofcom ruled lies can’t hurt us? Rory Bremner has the last laugh.

Britain’s broadcasting watchdog ‘Ofcom’ has rejected complaints about the documentary series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ brought by the series producer himself.

In rejecting the complaint Ofcom says that Gavin Hill was not entitled to complain as he did not feature in the series, nor was he connected to the subjects of the series, Thai police, tourists, police volunteers etc.

Gavin Hill

Gavin Hill

A complaint by Hill that the series also falsely repeatedly stated that last year 288 Brits were killed in Thailand, when in fact that was the number of Brits who had just died in Thailand, was also rejected as Ofcom judged that this ‘would not  result in material harm to viewers ‘

The controversial series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ was originally sold by Hill as ‘Thai Cops’ to comedian Rory Bremner’s company Vera Productions and went out earlier this year on the ‘Bravo’ Channel in Britain.

Hill, former APTV chief in Singapore,  had complained that the company had failed to fact check when they edited in London and had made some unethical cuts to alter the reality of situations.

Dean Palmer Does he read his email?

Dean Palmer Does he read his email?

Roger Riach, the son of a Scots woman who died after being mugged in Bangkok has also complained about the television series. Despite the London executive producer Dean Palmer having been notified of her death, which in any case was widely reported in the press, the programme reported two weeks ago that Lydia Riach was still alive and Thai police were hot on the trail of her killer. They also named Dougie and Roger Riach, her husband and son, as ‘ Tony’ and ‘John’ without any explanation.

Said Gavin Hill: “This is just the sort of stuff I have been up against. I emailed Dean Palmer with the full update about Lydia’s death.”

 It is believed the report was included to replace another jet-ski incident,  after a showdown with Royal Marines in Phuket and a jet-ski operator,  caused wide controversy in Thailand

 The text of the Ofcom rejection follows below:

 Wed, 28 Oct 2009 23:51
Subject: Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand: Bravo Ref: 1-129444255
Dear Mr Hill
 
Thank you for submitting a fairness and privacy complaint form.
 
I note you are the programme maker of the series Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand but that you do not appear in nor are referred to in the programme.
In order to bring a complaint of unfair treatment in the programme as broadcast or unwarranted infringement of privacy in the making or broadcast of a programme, our criteria for “person affected” must be satisfied. In accordance with our procedures for handling fairness and privacy complaints (copy attached), the “person affected” is a person who is a participant in a programme and is the subject of the alleged unfair treatment or unwarranted infringement of privacy or has a direct interest in the subject matter of the alleged unfair treatment or unwarranted infringement of privacy and if a direct interest  then that the interest is sufficiently direct.
 
Having read your complaint, I note you were not a participant in the programme nor were you referred to. The subject matter of the programme complained of appears to be the work of the Thai Police authorities. As the programme maker you therefore do not have a direct interest in the subject matter of the programme.  Furthermore, the issues you raise are potential issues of unfairness in the making of the programme and this falls outside of Ofcom’s remit. Broadcasters have the right to editorial freedom when making programmes providing, in the case of fairness and privacy, it does not result in unfairness in the broadcast programme or unwarranted infringement of privacy in the making or broadcast of the programme to a “person affected”.
 
With regard to your complaint about accuracy relating to the opening statement in the programme that last year 288 Britons were killed in Thailand, this has been assessed under the Standards section of the Ofcom Broadcasting Code (“the Code”) under Harm and Offence.
 
We assess such matters against Rule 2.2 of the Code, which directs that factual programmes or items or portrayals of factual matters must not materially mislead the audience, but is intended to deal with content which materially misleads the audience so as to cause harm rather than accuracy per se.
While we acknowledge your distinction between describing someone being killed and dying, in this particular context, which was simply a factual reference to the number of deaths, we don’t judge this would result in material harm to viewers in the sense of our rules.
I am sorry that we cannot consider your complaint further but thank you for contacting Ofcom. 
 
Kind regards
 
 Julia Snape

Fairness & Privacy,Content & Standards

 

Comment: No surprises here but its nice to know that Ofcom appears to support the notion that false information cannot harm us.

Hill and Palmer when times were good!

Hill and Palmer when times were good!

But whatever happens these chaps will not be sitting in the same love-seat anymore.

The shot here was taken in happier times before Dean Palmer left to supervise the edit in the UK.

The R in Vera is Rory Bremner and the A is Geoff Atkinson, Bremner’s producer and partner in the company. Actually Geoff, with whom I have been in correspondence over BTIT, is one of Britain’s top comedy writers and producers and has written for Cannon and Ball, Ronnie Barker, as well of course from Bremner.

He has also made some serious investigative docs.

His series ‘Heil Honey I’m home’ based on Adolf Hitler and Eva Braun sharing a house in the suburbs was however taken off after one episode.

Well I can see the humour there, after all we have had the ‘Producers’, ‘Allo Allo’ and ‘Hogan’s Heroes all taking the fun out of the Nazis. Perhaps it was ahead of its time.

Dean Palmer is a different sort of fish to track down although his background on zoominfo includes such greats as ‘I’m a Celebrity Get me out of here’, ‘Survivor’, Dispatches etc,  Assignment and The Big Story further searches have revealed little more. However on Vera’s website he is listed as one of the company’s ‘two thinkers’. One of his programme’s ‘Sky Crimes’ was apparently short-listed for an Emmy, but when I looked up Sky Crimes he was not on the list of major credits which included producer or director.

Gavin Hill has more of a news background starting as sound broadcaster in Picaddily Radio, Manchester, he went on to be APTV’s man in Singapore and has reported from Afghanistan, Peru, and umpteen more places and we were both on the hunt for Nick Leeson.

He has also been a Hollywood TV reporter based out of LA, an instructor in television journalism,  worked for ‘Real TV and  subsequently even gave a talk once entitled: ‘Quality TV - My part in its downfall’, though I think (I hope) that was self effacement rather than a real statement of fact.

Mind you he does have a dark television secret involving a giant rubber ball and the Grand Canyon, I believe. I haven’t got to the bottom of that yet. :-)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Iguana handlers in Soi Crocodile Veggie Fest protest

This is a blog only

As if Phuket is not getting enough bad PR at the moment, the Phuket Gazette is reporting a punch up between a Middle iguana02Eastern tourist and three ‘Iguana handlers’ after the tourist apparently declined to be photographed being pictured with one of these creatures in, yes, Soi Crocodile.

The 20-yr-old Syrian ended up being stabbed with a pocket knife.

A novelty holiday picture - if you are visiting Belize

A novelty holiday picture - if you are visiting Belize

Here’s a hint about buying Iguanas. Don’t.  They can grow up to five feet and won’t fetch your morning paper, wai, or even chase the local cat.

Why ‘Iguana handlers’, who are guys with no experience of Iguanas but have bought them illegally to make a fast buck, are allowed to pester people in Patong says a lot about the country’s promise to eradicate the trade in wild life.

Getting a picture taken with a ladyboy however IS contributing to the local wild-life.

As its Phuket Vegatarian Festival however here is a link to a recipe for Iguana.

http://www.mex-recipes.com/recipes-mexican-food.html

Finally a link from my colleague Andy Chant http://apiln.blogspot.com/  If you think your lot is bad have a heart for these people who are going through hell in the UK and telling their local newspapers about it.

Big Trouble in Thailand - finally the truth and an apology

This is a blog only

btit-crew-shot-jetty1

Today my friends at Phuketwan are reporting that all jet-skis in Patong Beach are now insured. This is now perhaps the time to put the lid on an incident in June this year involving a row over a damaged jet ski, British Royal Marines, and a payment of 35,000 Thai baht. etc…. and reveal the truth.

The series producer of ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ Gavin Hill was not present for the edit in London and as such he appears to have been unable to stop some sharp editing during the jet ski scene in which some audio was pulled in from elsewhere to apparently make the scene look more dramatic.

The film, showing on the minority Bravo channel in the UK with just some 100,000 plus viewers, has apparently caused quite some controversy including threats to arrest the Thai fixers and a meeting between the London producers and the Thai Ambassador in London. 

Actually personally I found it quite a true reflection on life in certain tourist areas in Thailand though of course it cannot speak from a very high moral plain because of some careless edits, and all the bells, whistles, repetitions, clanging prison doors etc. Lets face it its a film for chavs but it has entertained many of us especially as the chav narrator kept going on about Foo-ket and Patt-aye-ya.

As no foreigner is going to apologise for the jet ski stuff  I now take it upon myself to apportion blame where of course it is truly deserved and apologise on everyone’s behalf.

“Dear Sir,
As a journalist based in Thailand I feel it is my duty to apologise for the wrong assumptions and unfair media treatment Thailand received this year over an incident involving a ‘damaged’ jet-ski, the Royal Marines and a very respectable businessmen called JJ.

Just a toy. That's so bloody obvious

Just a toy. That's so bloody obvious

Contrary to reports overseas, the jet ski hirer Marine Jack Tebbott, 21, was in fact so mortified about damaging the jet ski in question that he walked three miles to the jet-ski owners private premises to apologise and was not, as some reports suggest, taken there against his own will.
In addition he called his friends in the Royal Marines to help him with the apology as he thought a group apology would be better and carry far more weight.
He admitted many times that he was guilty even though he rather thought, that as the damage was to the side of the boat, his left leg might have noticed.
He even called in his boss in the Marine Police, Sergeant Tim Wright to apologise too.
The man known as JJ had described on camera how he dealt with foreigners who did not pay up. But this gesture of slapping his fist into his hand could not in any way be interpreted as an indication of physical violence.  In any case knowing how journalists operate it was probably taken from his cookery programme in which he demonstrates how to grind spices for tom yam kung.

Playful banter. Tim and JJ sharing a joke as Marine Jack Tebbott chuckles in the background

Playful banter. Tim and JJ sharing a joke as Marine Jack Tebbott chuckles in the background

Indeed it is quite clear from the documentary ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’, that footage which showed Marines and JJ laughing and joking and making small talk was in fact substituted with audio suggesting that they were alarmed when JJ produced what was obviously a toy gun. What pussycats!  Further what was not explained in the programme is that JJ said that his bosses do not like him using guns as they are the guys who actually do.
Clearly the sound track which was not translated for the British audience, and which appeared to show JJ saying to himself : “These motherfuckers  not (going to) mess with me’  must have come from a totally different incident , also his reference to the Marines as ‘mun’ (jerks in this context).
There clearly is a cut in the film during the gun scene which makes things suspicious. I am sure it cannot be because of the feeble excuse that JJ told the crew not to film either of the other two guns in his armoury.
There is of course a sequence which shows some swearing between the Marine Police Sergeant and JJ. This friendly banter has of course been wildly distorted. 

There was a sequence in the film which also shows JJ saying that if the stain on the fibre glass is brown – then the damage is old.
Sergeant Wright pointed out that the stain in this case was also brown.  But it was decided by mutual agreement that in this case the brown meant that it was new damage.
Marine Jack was more than happy to pay out 35,000 Thai baht in damages and Tim and JJ were so happy that they settled in a spirit of warm conviviality and can clearly be seen shaking hands.
In fact one Marine was so deliriously happy that he had to be held back by his comrades from giving JJ a Glasgow kiss. 

Why were JJ's men not allowed to wear their suits?

Why were JJ's men not allowed to wear their suits?

Marine Sergeant Wright is not as JJ says, his father, pa, or dad, and JJ is indeed a normal person and a businessman.  I am also appalled at the cutaways to JJ’s colleagues covered all over with tattoos and being made to look menacing. So why did the filmmakers not give them the opportunity to look as smart as Sergeant Wright?

 But no! These film companies, who are obviously out to trash Thailand, do not show these sort of things do they!  Good news is not news is it!

Jet ski operators Phuket happily agree to massive discounts or something else at Phuketwan

Jet ski operators Phuket happily agree to massive discounts or something else at Phuketwan

Two policemen arrived at the same time as Sergeant Tim Wright and of course had anything untoward happened they would have done something.
In fact when JJ is negotiating he says his uncle is the local police chief, showing that he is indeed an upstanding citizen, I believe they even joined in a chorus together with Marine Jack in: “We are men. We are men. We are not ladyboys. We are not katoeys. We don’t run.”
To be quite frank, as Sergeant Wright has pointed out, Royal Marines were involved in five other jet ski incidents in June in two days in Patong Beach, Phuket, and had to pay damages on each occasion.
This quite clearly shows that these guys know nothing at all about boats and watercraft.
  They should not be allowed out to sea at all!

Sergeant Wright is mistaken when he refers accidentally to the jet ski operator as a  ‘two bit low-life’.  Either that or this was taken from another section when he was talking about the cameraman.

Thailand has lots of lovely beaches - and jet skis

Thailand has lots of lovely beaches - and jet skis

In fact jet-skis are really quite sophisticated machines which should not really put in the hands of foreigners.

 Due to their lack of sklls under Thai law foreigners are not allowed to operate any vessel, powered or sail, based in Thailand without an authorised Thai Captain looking over their shoulder.

Proof is in the fact that between December and April this year in Chaweng Beach, Koh Samui, over 150 foreigners, operating without Thai Captains, had to pay up for damages.


In conclusion the Thai Film Board, Tourism Authority etc, Channel 3 and the Bangkok Post are all quite right in their assumptions.  Anybody Thai who had a hand in the making of ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ and did not collude in showing a favourable image to the country should be brought to trial.
And JJ, who had no history of firearms offences ( well apart from an incident three day before the  Marines arrived ) should therefore receive an apology from the producers forthwith.
PS: The 500 baht taxi fare from Kalim to Patong is a very good deal by the way. Why are all these foreigners complaining. They’re all rich are they not?

Disrespecting Thai culture. Foreigners in lock up after Full Moon party on Koh Phangnan

Disrespecting Thai culture. Foreigners in lock up after Full Moon party on Koh Phangnan

 

 

 

May I take this opportunity to also apologise for the outrageous slur made against the police in Koh Phangan who it was alleged ( well it was not, but the Police Chief in Koh Phagnan says it was) profiteered monthly from the drugs arrests at the Full Moon Parties. These people are disrespecting Thai culture by bringing their drugs culture to this small island. It is up to the Thai police to use the full powers of the law to eradicate this problem. Nevertheless people have been treated with leniency and mercy.  I would like to point out the girl in question got bail ( as they always do) and went to court (as everybody does) and received due justice and mercy in Thailand. This had nothing to do with the cameras being present. It would be outrageous to suggest that all the other people paid themselves off with figures up to and over 60,000 baht on pain of going to jail,  and this was the only druggie the filmmaker could find,  who had to go through the process as she could not scrape the bribe together.

 

 
 

 

Ruining Thai culture. Restaurant menu on Haad Rin beach Koh Phangnan

Ruining Thai culture. Restaurant menu on Haad Rin beach Koh Phangnan

Acknowledgement: With thanks to the painstaking research by Talen and Thailandlandofsmiles.com

 

 

However it appears that neither Marine Sergeant Tim Page nor Gavin Hill agree with my researcher Talen, who has been digging deep from his huts in Nakon Phanom and Mukdahan and I suppose in the interests of fairness I have to reprint these letters to him.

 

Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright

Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright

Police did ’sweet fanny Adam’

From Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright, 40 Commando, Taunton, Somerset

Talen

I have just found this site (www.thailandlandofsmiles.com) and as you seem to have taken an aversion to my methods let me put you in the picture about the incident, which I see Gavin Hill has already commented on.

I was called to the scene, one of numerous similar incidents I had been called to that week, and had been informed that a gun had been pulled on a group of Royal Marines by a local ‘business man’! It was not my intent on arrival at a scene to allow that weapon or any other to be drawn again. As for not calling the local police, they were there, I didn’t have to, my Thai colleagues had called them and they sat around doing nothing, just waiting for the money to be handed over and for us to leave. If the lad had not already made a deal with JJ, I would have removed them from the scene and told him to take him to court. He would not have done because he knew it was a scam.

This onging corruption and criminality spoils a beautiful country and a very generous and loving people. I saw many tourists being scammed by the jet ski hire people, it is something I would warn anybody visiting Thailand against doing, along with motorbike hire, drugs and ladyboys.

The whole visit to Phuket was marred for many of the young me and women I was policing by such scams, and it would be far more productive for you to try and remove that blight from your golden beaches than to insult law abiding tourists who bring much needed foreign currency to your country.

I am an honourable man and I would like an apology for your comments about me. To insult me as you have and caste doubts as to my character and professionalism deeply saddens me I can only hope you never fall foul of a similar con.

your aye

Tim
And this from Gavin Hill, formerly of Bravo Productions

Hi Talen –
So, you cracked the case hey? Solved the mystery?
With quite a bit of help along the way from the trustyswordoftruth it would appear
Mike’s correct in saying neither Tim nor I needed to respond to you, and I think you have been unnecessarily adversarial and impolite, given our contribution to your blog.
I think you have been confused as to who the ‘enemy’ is at times.
You do owe Tim an apology. He was acting in the very best interests of his men and very bravely. Some of your comments do suggest naivete as to the way things work on the ground in situations like this – in Thailand and many other places too for that matter.
I know you’ll get very defensive about this, but it would be magnanimous of you if you did.
Vera Productions are threatening to sue – they don’t like the release of any footage which shows how they doctored sound which contributed to a man’s arrest and imprisonment.
Now, whoever uploaded that video to You Tube did so in the public interest – because I would imagine they believe in professionalism, balance and fairness, that factual entertainment shouldn’t be at the expense of factual accuracy.
I would imagine they also believe that their credibility and that of the series is compromised by factual inaccuracy, attempts at fabrication, misleading information (288 Brits “killed” last year in Thailand) and the unnecessary dramatisation of very real events, such as JJ and the Marines. Mispronunciation of place names is just pathetic.
But I expect they felt powerless to do anything about it in the face of rampant sensationalism, disregard for old fashioned journalistic values and threatened legal might.
The fact remains, however it was (mis)represented by Vera Productions/Virgin Media, that JJ introduced a gun into a very tense situation (the audio over the gun shots came from a scuffle between JJ and one of the Marines that wasn’t cut into the broadcast programme, but should have been). The gun was threatening, although I don’t believe the line of v/o should have said that.
As the creator, producer, director and cameraman of ‘Big Trouble In Thailand’ but with little or no input into the editing process my misgivings, or should I say fury, began when Virgin Media at the last minute changed the working title ‘Thai Cops’ to ‘Big Trouble In Tourist Thailand’. I complained – in the strongest possible terms – that this would be a slap in the face of the Thai authorities who so kindly gave me such unrivaled and unique access. If I’d said we were making ‘Big Trouble In Tourist Thailand’ I seriously doubt we would have been permitted to do what we did. Had the title not been so provocative – personally I saw it as an attack on Thailand’s tourism industry – and had the JJ scenes been edited in a more balanced manner (as had been the case in the rough cut I was sent to look at) then I think the series would have received less adverse attention and certainly attracted less controversy. I might not be facing arrest and imprisonment there. After all, it is only a very minor series being watched largely by young males who amount to the population of a small english town – at most.
But … yes, then there is You Tube which does make a difference these days.
But people have got a bit carried away nevertheless.
Me? I’m just a stickler for truth insofar as it’s possible to tell it, and getting the balance right. Thai Cops was also my idea and it had enormous potential. It was a tricky proposition, I’ll admit, but everything was going swimmingly until the content we’d gathered in the field was handed over to Vera Productions in London. Everyone was on board – from JJ and the Marines to the Thai police and prison authorities.
Regardless of what anyone might think of JJ, there was absolutely no justification for faking the audio.
Though I was not responsible for doing so, I do apologise to the viewers that my idea for a highly-watchable Thai police series came to this.
I think it’s about time that reality TV got its house in order and production companies opened a dictionary and looked up the world “integrity”. This way we who work in the industry, in this genre, can hold our heads high in the knowledge we’re not disrespecting the TV viewer who would, I’m sure, like to believe that reality TV can either be trusted, or if not, carry a warning in the way cigarette packets do – along the lines of your summation Talen … don’t believe all you see or hear.
So the truth was out there, wasn’t it?

 

Talen at ThailandLandof Smiles has as usual demanded the last word.

So you, tabloid scum,  think you are a journalist, Tim thinks he is something big in the military and Gavin thinks he is some swanky film producer. You can all argue until to are blue in the face but I can tell you I work on facts gleaned from some 150 hours watching and re-watching the videos, and by nicking stuff off other blogs and quoting them out of context to make my site look better!

You tell you I know nothing, but let me tell You I know f*ck all!  Did you like my blog on Mukdahan by the way. Freudian eh. Me pretending to look for a whore but only finding this woman’s luscious dim sum. Bet that had you in a sweat! (enough now Ed).

Phuket Bungy jump - the bare truth exposed

This is a blog only

Link to Daily Mail and Video

phuketbungy02So it’s off to Phuket as the London Daily Mail requests ‘colour’ for the story it is going to publish about British student Rishi Bavjeva, who took a flying leap this summer attached to a bungy cord – and never came up again.
The Phuket Bungy jump has been promoting its 100 per cent safety record heavily but Bavjeva suffered a ruptured spleen, torn liver, collapsed lungs, and severe bruising, after become detached from the cord.
Bungy manager Terry Pearce told Phuketwan: ”We’ve had 140,000 jumps here over 17-and-a-half years,” he said. ”And this is the only one that went wrong.”

He has watched the video more than once, and in agonising slow-motion, reported the Phuket website.

”The guy didn’t listen to the jumpmasters,” Mr Pearce said. ”He went feet-first and his knees go up. He was young enough and strong enough to kick his way free.

”We’ve changed a couple of things since. The leg-wrapping we now use grips like hell. I’ve tried it myself.”

Well that’s nice to know.  Maybe they should just attach pensioners to these bungy cords.

I mean their site advertises the following:

  • Bungy Jump
  • Tandem Bungy
  • Catapult Bungy
  • Backwards Bungy
  • Water Touch Bungy
  • Well we all saw the video and I saw no evidence of him trying to kick himself free.  I just saw a guy take a massive high dive.
    Anyway despite the fact that Phuket Bungy claims it is fully insured Rishi is not going to bother to sue or claim.
    Now back to last week when Andy Chant went to do some back up and scene setting pictures for the Daily Mail.
    Seems it was not a good time to go!  The US Navy was in port in strength and the new sport is of course ‘Naked Bungy jumping’.

    weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!

    weeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!

    Well why do anything clothed when you can do it naked?  
    Poor old photo-journalist  Andy Chant had to sit around for hours photographing little more than flying bollocks.
    He also reported that the people actually fitting the punters into their feet harnesses were also all local.

    Look just let me hold my B*****ks

    Look just let me hold my B*****ks

    Look, they are probably fine, but with Thailand’s safety record its bound to make some people uneasy.
    “I thought the idea was that you just touched the water before the cord pulled you back up again,” said Andy.

    I guess so. They do advertise ’water touch’ as opposed to ‘kamikaze’.

    Apparently not. “Some guys went right under”. 

     ‘Meat and two veg and all’, as they say in the sarf London resort of Patt-ay-ya, all hitting the water with a giant thwack!

    I've got them all tucked up nicely this time

    I've got them all tucked up nicely this time

    British honeymoon couple survive Thai train horror

    From Andrew Drummond, Hua Hin
    Monday October 5th 2009

    Link to Daily Telegraph Link to Metro

    Link to Daily Mail   Link to Daily Express

     

    Pictures: Andrew Chant
    A British honeymoon couple today spoke of their miraculous escape from death when a train on the Orient Express line in Thailand crashed killing ten people and injuring over 50.
    Richard Stroud, 43, and his bride Dawn, 34, were thrown from their beds as the Bangkok bound train left the rails and crashed into another train. Their carriage came to an abrupt halt and then rolled twice sending the couple spinning.
    “It was like we were in space when the carriage rolled. One minute I saw Richard on the other side of the carriage, then he was gone, then he was there again. We were literally flying,” said Dawn, a retail manager at Home Bargains in Stroud.
    “I ended up on top of Richard then our beds ended up on top of us.”

    Honeymooners Dawn and Richard Stroud in Hua Hin Hospital

    Honeymooners Dawn and Richard Stroud in Hua Hin Hospital

    Richard and Dawn were heading back to Bangkok for a flight home last night after a two week holiday in Thailand, which began with two days in Bangkok, a week the northern capital Chiang Mai taking in some jungle trekking.
    For the last week they had gone south of the island of Koh Meuk in Thailand’s Trang Province. “It was idyllic. Because of the down turn in tourism we had a beach and a resort, which can accommodate 300 people, virtually all to ourselves”,  said Richard, Materials Manager for G.E. Aviation in Cheltenham, previously married with two sons.
    “We decided to take a first class cabin back to Bangkok taking the same route the Orient Express takes.  It may have saved our lives.  We were asleep when we were awoken by the whole train shuddering.
    “I shouted down to Dawn in the bottom bunk ‘What the hell is that!’.  Then suddenly we were both thrown out of our bunks.  I hit some metal, and then came down on the sink.  Then the train started rolling.
    “When we recovered it was pitch black but we found some lights we put on our heads for caving and switched them on. All around us we could hears moans and crying.
    “After a while rescuers came and they were very good.  They put a neck brace on me and pulled me up and out through a window as the train was on its side.
    “As we walked away we had to pick our way through mangled metal and wreckage and the bodies of those from a 2nd Class carriage, who were not so lucky.”
    Richard and Dawn Stroud will have to wait two weeks before they are allowed to fly back to the hometown which bears their name – Stroud.  Doctors have told Richard he is not fit to fly in the meantime.
    He has two fractured ribs and bad body bruising.
    Thai State Railways Governor  Yuthanna  Thapcharoen said: “Among the 10 people dead is a 2-yr-old girl.  We have already begun an enquiry into why the train left its tracks and I cannot comment further.”
    The Thai News  Agency said a switching error may have been the cause of the crash near Hua Hin, a Thai beach resort 150 miles south of Bangkok early this morning.  The train was due in Bangkok at 08.25am.
    But it is also being  reported that the train’s driver had gone through a red signal and that the train was travelling too fast to successfully traverse a junction.
    NB: Foreign/Home News Desks: final death toll and injuries likely to change:
    Ends.-

    Two young Brits die in boat tragedy in Halong Bay UPDATED

    From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, Monday September 28

    Link to Daily Mail

    Link to the SUN

    Link to Evening Standard Link to Daily Telegraph

     

    From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, Monday September 28
    An inquiry was launched today into how five passengers died including two young Britons when a brand new tourist boat sank in Vietnam on just its second passenger trip.
    Timothy Roney and Karen Puddifoot

    Timothy Roney and Karen Puddifoot

    From reports in the country’s Quang Ninh province it has already been established that the boat was neither insured nor allowed to operate after dark when the accident happened in a tropical storm late last week.
    The young Britons aged Tim Roney, 22 and Karen Puddifoot, 27, were cycling around the world to raise cash for the British Lung Foundation.  They were among 25 passengers on the tourist three story cruiser on Halong Bay in the Gulf of Tonkin, when storms, which have been ravaging south east Asia for the last week, struck.
    The British friends, from Northwood, set off on their trip in June and aimed to cycle 21,000 miles through 12 countries. Before leaving Mr Roney, a ski instructor, said: “I’ve always dreamed of doing something like this. A few people have told me I must be mad but this is the biggest adventure of my life.”
    In a statement Mr Roney’s family said: “Tim was extremely sociable, talented and adventurous and always had a smile on his face.”
    Ms Puddifoot’s family said: “She was talented, hard working, independent, strong-willed and brave. Losing Karen has left a deep hole in our family.” A former Watford Grammar School for Girls pupil, Ms Puddifoot studied at Wimbledon School of Art before working in the film industry.

    Typical Halong Bay junk

    Typical Halong Bay junk

    The boat they had chosed in Halong Bay was the boat’s first outing apart from one earlier trip under-going sea trials, it was reported  today.
    Two Vietnamese and a Frenchman also drowned in the incident yesterday. Other passengers were treated for shock and minor injuries. The British couple had boarded the boat at Ti-Tong island along with the French man.  The incident happened an hour after dusk last Thursday.
    A spokesman for the Foreign and Commonwealth Office said today: “Our consular officials from Hanoi are providing consular assistance”.
    “Arrangements are being made through an insurance company to fly their bodies home.”
    British Embassy officials travelled to Halong Bay, some 100 miles east of the capital, Hanoi, to help officials confirm the identify the two UK travellers.
    The boat sank in strong winds and choppy waters as it was returning to port last Thursday evening. Twenty-five tourists and seven crew members were on board.
    The boat QN-5298, owned by the Bien Mo Company, was heading for Cat Hai island in neighbouring Haiphong Province when it was hit by the storm, the Captain Do Long told police.   The boat capsized and water filled two of the three levels, spilling the passengers and crew into the water. Some passengers were able to climb to the third level.
    The passengers were buffeted by high winds, rough waves, and driving rain.
    The survivors were picked up by other boats which rushed to the scene.
    According to Thahnien newspaper in Vietnam the brand new boat built at a cost of £360,000 said Pham Van Bac, the director of the Bien Mo Company,  and was considered to be the “biggest and most beautiful in the area” but it was not insured and not licensed yet to operate at night.
    An investigation has been launched by Quang Ninh police and the provincial authority.

    British woman ‘raped’ by taxi driver in coconut plantation -Thailand

    From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, Sunday September 27
    Link Daily Mail Link to Daily Express

    Link Daily Telegraph Link to Metro

    A 28-year British woman, who hired a taxi driver to take her back to her room on the Thai holiday island of Koh Samui, was instead taken to a  coconut plantation, dragged screaming from the car, beaten and  then raped,it was claimed today.
    After the attack the woman was then robbed of her cash and dumped by the road to walk home.
    Today police charged a 21-yr-old local taxi driver with rape and are questioning an accomplice who used his pick-up to dump the woman referred to as ‘Lilly’ (not real name) afterwards and then robbed her of 1,700 Thai baht (£31.60p)
    Police on Koh Samui say that the 21-yr-old driver picked up the woman, an English Language teacher,   as a fare early on Saturday morning in Chaweang Beach, but drove past the woman’s lodgings in Lamai Beach and took her instead to house in coconut plantation.
    “He dragged her out of the car against her will and beat her in the process. He then raped her in the house,” said Deputy Police Commander Paiboon Krajakchan.

    “His friend arrived in a pick-up and then friend then transferred the semi-conscious woman to a pick-up truck and dumped her beside the road near Lamai.  He took all her money.”
    Katherine Horton

    Katherine Horton

    Paiboon Krajakchan said: “We are treating this matter seriously. It is important that Koh Samui is seen as a safe destination for tourists.”
    Koh Samui has been the scene of a number of rapes of British and foreign tourists. The most infamous case was that of Katherine Horton who was raped and murdered on Lamai Beach on New Year’s day 2006 by two fisherman who boasted to friends that she was ‘fun and delicious’.
    The fishermen were sentenced to death, reduced later to life imprisonment.

    Camera director of ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ makes ‘tactical withdrawal’

     

    From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok,
    September 20 2009

    Pictures Gavin Hill/Vera
    A British producer cameraman has had to flee Thailand after filming a sequence in which British Royal Marines were held at gunpoint by Thai mafia after hiring a Jet Ski on a paradise beach.
    The cameraman Gavin Hill, 40, from Manchester, a former bureau chief for Associated Press Television, was today back in London, after fleeing Bangkok, as his Thai crew faced up to a year in jail.
    They stand accused of assisting in the filming of a sequence which could ‘damage the country’s image’.  A battle with the Thai authorities has raged for two weeks.
     Hill, who also produced ‘Crime Squad’ for the BBC with Sue Lawley, and a series for Real TV said today (Sunday) :  “I’ve made a tactitcal withdrawal  and am in London to discuss how we can help our Thai colleagues.  But yes, I did not wish to argue my case from prison.

    Marine Tebbott, JJ, and producer cameraman Gavin Hill

    Marine Tebbott, JJ, and producer cameraman Gavin Hill

    “We filmed the mafia but suddenly we are the criminals apparently. The atmosphere is a little bit hysterical. The Marines are behind me thank god. ”
    The gun incident happened on Phuket when a young marine Jack Tebbott  from Leicester was kidnapped by tattooed mafia figures, who control what’s for sale on Phuket’s  Patong Beach.
    Twenty-one-year old Tebbott  was seized after his colleagues from Delta Company 40 Commando told a scammer to ‘get lost’ after they were presented with a bill for 60,000 Thai baht (£1094) for damaging  a jet ski which they had hired.
    The marines, from  40 Commando based in Taunton,  have lost three men fighting the Taliban in Helmand province of Afghanistan. Delta section’s most famous Marine is Joe Townsend who lost his legs in a mine explosion. 
    They had been warned about the scam and told not to hire jet skis  before after arriving on HMS Bulwark in June, but did not anticipate coming up against a gunman in a Thai holiday resort.
    Gavin Hill had received permission from the Thai authorities to film a series called ‘Thai Cops’ , a reality show which followed British volunteers in the Thai Tourist Police dealing with the hundreds of thousands of  British tourists  who travel to Thailand every year.  However ,as a result of this incident and others, the title of the series had to be changed to ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’.
    The Marines incident happened after producers received complaints from tourists and went to a Jet Ski operator called Winai Naiman, nicknamed JJ, to get his side of the story.
    On camera he admitted beating up tourists if they did not pay.

    The foreign and Thai production crew for 'Big Trouble in Thailand'

    The foreign and Thai production crew for 'Big Trouble in Thailand'

    Then he called the production crew to film after catching Marine Tebbot and taking to him his yard three miles from the beach.  Unknown to him Hill was also filming with the Marines.  Naiman brought out a gun with a telescopic sight after a section of Delta Company react to a distress call.
    The affair was settled after the arrival of  Marine Police Sergeant  and Detatchment Commander Tim Wright, from London, who told Naiman his was ‘corrupt and a crook’ after examining the jet ski and finding the damaged area had already turned brown proving it was old.  But Sergeant Wright finally agreed to pay 35,000 baht, over £600.
    Royal Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright said at the 40 Commando base in Somerset: “I got my men out of that situation without claret being spilt and that was the important thing.
    “The Thais are trying to say my men were not threatened or held at gunpoint.  But by doing this they are questioning my integrity. I do not like my integrity being questioned especially by a two bit crook.
    “We will make representations to the Foreign Office. The warning to tourists is not sufficient.
    “ If Thailand wants to make a fuss about this I am happy to support the producer and raise the level to that of diplomatic incident.  The case of Marine Tebbott was not the only case of extortion I had to deal with, not by far.”
    The Foreign Office advisory warns traveller to ensure that the people whom they hire jet skis from are reputable. But they do not warn specifically about the extortions involved and that violence has been used.
    Tourists have been milked for as much as 200,000 bat during these incidents in Thailand according to a group of foreign consuls, who estimated on the Thai island of Koh Samui  jet ski operators, working with local police, had  scammed nearly £100,000 out of tourists between December and April of this year.
    “In almost all cases the police are called they make the tourists pay out and then they get the commission from the jet ski operators.  In most cases it is old damage. In a case of new damage the cost of repair would not normally be more than £50, ” a local consul said on condition of anonymity.

    Filming with Thai Tourist Police in Phuket

    Filming with Thai Tourist Police in Phuket

    A spokesman for the Thai film board said the crew had violated Article 34 of the motion picture law by not having the contents examined by a Tourism and Sports Ministry film committee before they were broadcast abroad.
    And Seksan Nakawong, director-general of the Office of Tourism Development, said the film-makers also violated Article 23 of the same law for making a film tarnishing the reputation of Thailand.  The penalties are a £18,000 fine and a year in jail or both.
    Meanwhile Police  Lt. Gen Santhan Chayanont, chief of Provincial Police Region 8, whose officers are accused of being involved in the scams,  says he has ordered his men to bring in all the Thai ‘collaborators’ .
    40 Royal Marine Commando lost one  officer  Lt. John Thornton and two men, Marine David Marsh and Marine and Corporal Damian Mulvihill  during a seven month tour of duty fighting the Taliban in Helmand Province in 2008.

    Royal Marine Joe Townsend

    Royal Marine Joe Townsend

    The actions  and conduct of Delta Company’s Marine Joe Townsend, who lost both his legs in a mine explosion in Afghanistan, have been held up in the UK as a shining example of courage of the British forces.

    Marine Townsend recently accompanied Britain’s Prince Harry to New York to meet US serviceman who had lost limbs in Afghanistan and Iraq.

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Karen Elephant Patrol -Andrew Drummond. See comments below

    Karen Elephant Patrol -Andrew Drummond. See comments below

    British Royal Marines ready to go to ‘war’ over Thai gun confrontation

    (More rushes from ‘Big Trouble in Thailand)

    “Thailand is awesome. The people are good and sound. Today was a bit different” - Marine Jack Tebbott

    Link: JJ: My uncle is big Captain in police station
    From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, September 13
    Royal Marines who claim they were swindled and held at gunpoint while on R&R in Thailand said tonight that they were ‘ready to go to war’ over an alleged cover-up of the incident.

    Royal Marine Face-offThe Marines of Delta Company, 40 Commando, based in Taunton, who were held at gunpoint by a Jet Ski operator on the Thai holiday island of Phuket, said they would take the matter to government to government level, if Thai authorities tried to shift the blame.
    And they added that they would stick by a British producer/cameraman, who filmed the whole incident, and who now faces arrest  accused by the Thai authorities of ‘setting up’ the scene for filming.
    “The Thai authorities should choose to hold an adult approach to this incident. If not, we are willing to raise the level of this dispute to that of a diplomatic incident, though of course we will have to go through legal channels,“ said Marine Police Sergeant and Detachment Commander Tim Wright.
    The row follows an incident which happened when Delta Company were on ‘R &R’ on the Thai holiday island of Phuket earlier this year.

    Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright (right) confronts JJ

    Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright (right) confronts JJ

    The marines were held at gun-point and surrounded by Thai thugs after one of their number, 21-yr-old Marine Jack Tebbott, from Leicester, was accused of damaging  a jet-ski and faced demands of over £1,200 in compensation.
    Violence was only avoided when Royal Marine Police Sergeant Tim stepped and agreed to authorise a payment.

    Marine Sergeant Tim Wright

    Marine Sergeant Tim Wright

    The whole scene was captured on film by British cameraman producer Gavin Hill. The Jet Ski thug, known as JJ, has since been arrested on charges of extortion. But he has given a statement saying that the film was set up.
    Yesterday Thai authorities began steps to try and block a series currently running on a minor British television  channel and they said they wanted to question the producer over the ‘set up’.
    They have also countermanded all ‘film release’ forms which were required for the filming and transmssion. Last night Royal Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright from London said: “From what I gather people in Thailand are trying to impugn the reputation of the Royal Marines and of the producer cameraman involved.
    “I have told the producer cameraman Gavin Hill that I and the lads will stand by him. What he recorded on film was the absolute truth.  I do not like my integrity or that of the Marines being questioned. I live by my integrity.
    “I especially do not like my integrity being questioned by a two bit swindler.  If need be we will escalate this to a diplomatic incident.  We also would like to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office to put out an official warning on their Travel Advisory to Thailand.
    “It is quite alarming to see how the film maker s are being treated. The Thais should be dealing with the problem not trying to blame someone else.”
    The row over the ‘jet ski mafia’ began after the first of an eight part series called ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ went to air last Monday on the Bravo Channel.  The film shows the Commandos, who had arrived in Thailand on HMS Bulwark after a tour in Afghanistan’s Helmand Province, restraining themselves as the armed foul mouthed gang leader made his threats and demands for money.

    Marine Jack Tebbott

    Marine Jack Tebbott

    Although the channel has only a small audience in the UK, copies have been circulating heavily in Thailand.
    In the programme Marine Tebbott is accused of causing over £1000 worth of damage to a jet ski and eventually pays out the equivalent of £627.  But Sergeant Wright, who examined the boat, insisted that the damage was old, very old, by examining the stained fibre glass”
    He had already had to deal with other cases: “‘You are a crook. You are corrupt,” he tells JJ who replies: “I’m a f….g normal person. I am a businessman”.  In rushes released yesterday JJ also claims: “I’m not worried. My uncle is big police here!”
     A Royal Marine said later: “We could all have got out of there but there would have been claret spilt.”

    The ‘damaged jet ski’ con is widespread in Thailand and complaints have already been made by several Embassies, including the British, Australian and Chinese, to the Thai authorities.

    Prior to the film’s transmission the Provincial Governor had been ordered by Thailand’s Deputy Prime Minister to act to end the rip-offs to preserve the country’s image for tourism.

     Reliable reports say that corrupt police take a 20 per cent cut from all payments.

    Gavin Hill - hung out to dry?

    Gavin Hill - hung out to dry?

    Meanwhile producer Gavin Hill, who was working for comedian Rory Bremner’s Vera Productions, said: “At the moment our relationship has come to an end.  They have not given any support. They are also not honouring some promises I made to the Thai authorities or corrections I am making to the scripts. 

    “They appear to have left me out to dry. The Thai authorities are trying to get the series stopped.  But actually if they look at it closely they come off quite well.  We were primarily looking at British tourists on holiday. 
    “I actually love Thailand and would not wish to harm the country at all. The authorities cannot see who is doing the harm.”

    The series which was shot with the co-operation of the Thai Tourist Police was originally called ‘Thai Cops’. The title was then changed to ‘Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand’ and the Thai Film Board protested.
    “I told the production company that title was offensive to Thailand, but my views were apparently not ‘taken on board’ as they claimed they would be. It’s a mess.
    ““The situation with the Marines and JJ was real and menacing. It was not set up or scripted. I just recorded what happened”.

    JJ's boys look on

    JJ's boys look on

     

     

    .

    The Great Thai jet ski tourist scam - a producer bares all

    The series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ has provoked quite a controversy across the internet blogs in this part of the world and is now begining to hit the mainstream Thai media.

    Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright confronts JJ

    Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright confronts JJ

    Accusations have been made. Was the confrontation with the Marines set up? What sort of guy is JJ – the Thai mafia figure featured in this seemingly shaming episode for the Thai tourist industry.
    Anyway Gavin Hill the producer/director is throwing the issue wide open.  He says he has not formed a judgment, but of course the film had to be cut and edited, and it is apparent that although his comments were ‘taken on board’, perhaps not all were acted upon.
    You can form your own opinion of JJ by clicking on the following links.
     We all get edited. Make your own mind up. 

    Of course JJ may seem worse!  Personally I may have cut the film in pretty much the same way, I think the producer is entitled to make a judgment.   We start today with JJ on the beach whinging about bad tourists.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzeui3rC5yo

    and continue with him whinging on the beach. I rather picked up on the piece where JJ said : ” We call the police”

    http://www.youtube.com/user/BigTroubleInThailand#play/all/uploads-all/1/yFJsyJccTWE

    He believes a lot of foreigners have money to spare. He just needs to feed his family.

    They come off the beach tomorrow, Saturday, not before time, when I am sure we will hear about JJ’s police contacts!

     Meanwhile JJ has not sold himself to me, although to be sure there are some idiots hiring jet skis from time to time.

    Arrest follows ‘extortion’ of Royal Marines in Thailand

    Arrest follows British television documentary

    From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, September 9th 2009
    Pictures: Andrew Chant/Gavin Hill/

     

    Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

    Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

    Thai authorities have arrested the leader of a Thai mafia gang and charged with him with extortion based solely on the evidence of a British television documentary.
    Police today were holding a Thai known locally a JJ Naiman, aged 27, after he was seen on a British television programme trying to extort over £1000 from a British Royal Marine who had rented a jet-ski on the holiday island of Phuket.
    The province’s governor Wichai Praisa-nob also stepped into the row today and called a meeting of police, jet-ski operators, Marine Police, and local government officials to discuss what action would be taken. They are also to be shown the film. He said he was considering banning jet skis from the island.
    The British documentary ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’, which went to air on  Monday on the Bravo Channel, showed Royal Marines, who arrived in Phuket on HMS Bulwark, after a tour of Helmand Province, Afghanistan, being held at gun point in a local boat yard run by local mafia.
    Royal Marine Face-offThe row was only resolved after the arrival of Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright who defused the situation but not before exposing the Thai gangleader  as a ‘corrupt crook’.  The Marine Jack Tebbott, 21, from Leicester (right) eventually paid just over £600.
    Tim Wright said: “These men openly threatened serving military personnel whilst on R&R in Thailand. The important thing is that I got them out of there with no one being hurt, other than pride and in the wallet. I don’t remember swearing but apologise if I did! The other important thing to remember is don’t hire jet skis in Thailand.”
    The jet-ski con is widespread. Tourists are forced to pay for damage which they clearly have not created, but the mafia gangs have had assistance from corrupt police officers, who, according to one source, claim 20 per cent. 

    Copies of the programme are now widely available on the internet.   Further programmes could also embarrass Thailand.  A well known police rip-off on the island of Koh Phangan where police collect £10,000 every month from touriRoyal Marine Face-offsts on minor drugs charges on the threat of having to go to jail pending trial, is already getting exposure.  
    The boyfriend of one girl arrested says he received a demand to find £1,400 for possessing a small amount of cannabis, others had to pay more. For normal Thais the fine can be as little as £50.
    And a similar jet ski scam will also be exposed on the Thai island of Koh Samui.
    British Producer Gavin Hill said: “This was not designed to be an investigative programme. We just filmed what was going on in front of us.”
    He said however the next programme in the series probably reflected more on bad British behavior than that of Thais.

    “I am a little surprised at the big reaction now. This seems to have been going on for a long time.”

    JJ Naiman has been refused bail. Allegations that he had been paid to help set up the scene were described by Gavin Hill as ‘hardly credible’. “We had to cut a lot of the footage. I am satisfied that what was presented was the absolutely correct portrayal of the situation.  I have not taken any side.”

    Picture Special: Royal Marines in stand-off with Thai mafia

     
    Picture special:
     by Andrew Drummond, Bangkok

    Pictures: Andy Chant/Gavin Hill/Vera Productions

    Royal Marine Face-off

    (pops rewrite)
    Royal Marines fresh from a tour of duty fighting the Taliban in Afghanistan have been involved in armed stand-off with the mafia thugs on the Thai holiday island of Phuket.
    The marine ‘section’,  on exercise in South East Asia on ‘Operation Taurus’, faced down a mafia gun-man as they fought the same cause of hundreds of tourists who have been swindled at the top British holiday destination.

    I gotta get me a gun

    I gotta get me a gun

    The only reason blood was not spilled was because a Marine Police Sergeant stepped in to avoid a major international incident as the marines faced off with armed and tattooed Mafiosi who had been beating up tourists and ripping them off for thousands of pounds.
    Trouble began after HMS Bulwark made a port call in Phuket two months ago with the Marines who had just completed a tour of duty in Helmand Province.
    Within hours Shore Patrol policeman Matt Turner from Sheffield was reporting. “It’s mayhem.  Our lads, and hundreds of westerners are being fleeced and we believe it’s all by organised gangs.  Jet skis, taxis, everything.
    He added: “We have to help. We will do it whether its Marines or tourists being ripped off. We do not differentiate.”
    The boisterous Marines were officially warned by their officers not to hire jet skis on the beaches of the holiday island as this was the most expensive rip-off of all. Thailand has been hard hit by a tourist recession.
    But confident they could handle the situation, many ignored the ruling.

    Marine Jack Tebbott

    Marine Jack Tebbott

    Not long afterwards Marine 21-yr-old Jack Tebbott from Leicester found himself staring down the barrel of a gun after being taken to a  builders and boating yard in the back of beyond,  after allegedly damaging a jet-ski he had hired. The mafia were demanding 60,000 Thai baht £1,400 in damages and loss of earnings.
    Several tourists have already been beaten up for refusing to surrender to the mafia demands.
    Surrounded by the stripped to the waist thugs and held at the point of a rifle Tebbot had managed to get an sms message to his mates who arrived at the yard near Patong Beach on Phuket in ‘section force’.
    Bloodshed was only avoided when Marine Police Sergeant and Detatchment Commander Tim Wright arrived on the scene and told Tebbot: “Ok lad we told you not to hire jet skis. We know it’s a con but I’m afraid you’re now going to have to pay some money to get out of this.”

    No nonsense Marine Sgt Tim Wright

    No nonsense Marine Sgt Tim Wright

    Then  after examining the jetski the no nonsense Sergeant, who had already had to deal with other cases, turned on the mafia chief called JJ and said: “You’re a crook!  You’re corrupt.  The damage is old. The fibre glass has already turned brown.  How come all your jet-skis have a problem?”
    Then he turned to Marine Tebbot and said: “Ok boy. You go now!”
    JJ then ordered his thugs to block Tebbot’s exit but JJ perhaps sensing he had a fight on his hands continued negotiating.    The price eventually dropped by almost a half to 35,000 baht to (£627) but not before some other heated exchanges.
    “I’m just a f…cking businessmen. F..ck. You.  How are we to feed our families,” said JJ pointing to his fellow thugs lounging around and waiting for their next sucker.
    : ‘F..k you. You are not my father. You are not my pa.
    Sgt:“Don’t shout at me. You’re  crook. You’re a worm. You’re doing this day after day.

    Marine policeman Mat Turner

    Marine policeman Mat Turner

     

    JJ:F.. ck you!
    Sgt: F.ck you!’.
    The standoff ended when Marine Tebbot agreed to foot the bill. “Ok,” said Sergeant Wright,” you better toddle of to the ATM then.
    The Marines conceded afterwards that it was £627 too much but worth it to avoid an international incident.
    Said Sergeant Wright:  “They are trained to be cool. But had it come to the crunch we could have easily fought them and got all our lads out of there.  But there would have been some claret spilt on both sides.”

     

     

    Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

    Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

     The stand-off did however have a happy ending. After complaints from the British and other Embassies in Phuket the island’s police chief has ordered a crackdown on the thugs,  on the orders of Thailand’s Deputy Prime Minister, admitting that some policemen had also been pocketing cash with the local mafia.
    Police Commander Pigad Thantiphong , who admitted that the Royal Navy had also made a complaint  through the Embassy said: “Anyone who threatens tourists from now on will be prosecuted.  Any policeman who assists the mafia will be punished, and independent experts will be brought in to adjudicate in any case.”

    But how do we feed our families?

    But how do we feed our families?

    Amazingly the Marines standoff was captured on film by producer/director Gavin Hill which can be seen tonight(Monday) 10 pm in ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ made by comedian Rory Bremner’s Vera Productions for Bravo Channel  and filmed with the Thai Tourist Police.

    It was like this - you want to teach ME the art of public debating

    It was like this - you want to teach ME the art of public debating

     

    And despite the incident many marines still thought Phuket was the best place they had taken shore leave in.

    Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand

    The last time Royal Marines had a fight in Phuket