Tag Archive for 'Gavin Hill'

The script which ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ found in a teleprompter

Just when you thought this story had gone away now comes the news that Vera Productions have sold the controversial series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ to Channel 9 in Australia.

This will actually multiply its televion audience twenty fold. Previously it went out on Bravo with a viewership of about 116,000.

Vera Productions in the UK, run by comedian Rory Bremner and comedy producer/writer Geoff Atkinson has received accolades recently for its series ‘Bremner Bird and Fortune’.  However there has been a much publicised internal rift  between the series producer of ‘Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand’ Gavin Hill and the execs back in London, who were responsible for the edit.

There have been complaints of lack of fact checking and even unethically enhancing some scenes.

bird-and-fortuneIn its ‘Bremner, Bird and Fortune’ sketches- the two Johns -  Vera Productions has hilariously sent up the government and banking system. John Bird plays the character of George Parr. Fortune is the interviewer  However one sketch, based on the ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ series appears to have been left behind in a teleprompter.  I re-produce it here below.

But first follow this link for Bravo Television’s quiz  for intellectually challenged British tourists in Thailand. I failed it on the question ‘What do you do when arrested for drugs. Call the Embassy or your mum? I replied: ‘My mum. (Get your mum to call the Embassy!)

———————————————-

JF: George Parr - you are a top TV executive and you seem to have a success on your hands with the reality show Big Trouble In Thailand.

JB:  Yes, we’ve sold it to Virgin Media and they are delighted with the ratings … it’s exceeded all expectations…

JF: So, it was your idea to make a groundbreaking documentary about the British volunteers hired by Thailand’s police force to deal with misbehaving British holidaymakers?

JB: No. The idea was brought to us by a freelance filmmaker called Gavin Hill who realised that he needed a company of the stature of Rory Bremner’s Vera Productions to ensure credibility.

JF: So, he must have earned the riches of Croesus?  Because I understand the budget was 400,000 Pounds ?

JB: Well, not exactly - more like the salary of a provincial bus driver …

JF: Really? How so?

JB: Well, you have to understand how TV today works.  It’s all very well that one person comes up with the idea, produces, directs, films the material themselves … often working like a maniac … seventeen or eighteen hour days aren’t unusual … but that’s only part of the job.

JF: So, what do you mean exactly?

JB: Well, the footage has to be edited …

JF: Yes ….

JB: And then there’s the administration …

JF: Ah yes, of course, the administration.  And what form does that take exactly?

JB: Well, for example we have to ensure that Virgin Media’s money is spent wisely and that cash isn’t simply frittered away.

JF: And, how do you do that?

JB: Well, we sent one of our top men, Dean Palmer, First Class halfway round the world and put him in a luxury hotel to monitor the project … you know, keep his eye on things for two weeks.

JF: And did he?

santhiya02JB: Absolutely, for two weeks,  well, er, when he could get out of his hotel. Of course it was rather isolated and there was just one boat a day. Little bit pricey, eco-chic and set  in 18 acres of lush tropical forests on a crystal bay apparently, but thankfully not too close to the awful people he had to film.
Still the fact that he was on the ground, in situ, so to speak, speaks more than words.

JF: Lush tropical forests, crystal bays, eco-chic, we did not see much of that in the series?

JB: Oh good heavens. No. That would be totally outside the remit, old boy, and financial suicide. We leave that sort of stuff to Judith Chalmers. Is she still around?

JF: But I understand you went to the Thai authorities and said this series would be good for Thai tourism.

JB : Yes absolutely. And it is, it is, let me tell you. My young boys are straining at the leash for some Thai totty, not to mention the old fellows down at the British Legion, chumping at the bit they were. Some of them will be travelling with their nurses, must say it seems a bit superfluous to me, what?
JF: Ah indeed. But but from press reports, especially on the question of sex tourism, many, if not most of the illegal incidents in this area,  which one reads about  making the courts, appear to involve, dare I say it, erm,  man on boy, rather than girls. Why did you not tackle this subject?
JB:  Well obviously you’re not considering a much longer career in broadcasting.  There are things that we really need to keep sacred. In general the public likes a bit of straight old rumpy pumpy.  Going into the area you mention is an absolute minefield.  Well, we’d be hung out by our balls by our own community.   

In any case we had lots of what are described as ‘pre-op’ ladyboys who described in detail what  many Brits want, so we think we have that covered.

JF: I noticed also that you blurred out a lot of British faces but used all the Thai participants full on. Was there a reason for that?

JB: Absolutely. In Britain there are strict laws governning filming without permission. We have to get permission, period. They have to sign waivers.  When they do we have got them though,  can’t change their minds.  Can you imagine how difficult that is with all these people making an ass of themselves in front of our camera?  Quite a few were well tiddly when they signed judging by the signatures.  Now when it comes to ‘Johnny Foreigner’ well that’s a different kettle of fish.  With their one pound fifty a day earnings they are not going to take us on are they. I mean what lawyer is going to open the door for them.

JF:  … I see … but Hill must have been given a decent budget to have been able to achieve the very possibly award-winning footage he obtained in some pretty hairy situations - wasn’t he shooting in maximum security jails and confronting armed mafia men …?

JB: Well, to be honest we’re weren’t too pleased about that …

JF: Really? It seemed to me quite riveting TV …

JB: Ah yes … but there were some health and safety issues …. he should’ve let us know that he would find himself in some rather unsavoury situations.

JF: But surely the working title of this series was ‘Thai Cops’ - isn’t that what police officers do?

JB: Yes, yes … of course … but the safety of our operatives in the field is paramount.

Thai cops from Bravo Promo

Thai cops from Bravo Promo

JF: So, you would’ve preferred him to have filmed officers doling out parking tickets, would you …?

JB: Well, of course not - we would never have sold the show …

JF: So, part of the budget was spent on bodyguards for Mr Hill?

JB: Well … no, but we did send Emma - our twenty-five-year-old assistant producer with a first aid kit, and we have lots of police bar bills.

JF: I gather there were lots of interviews with top policemen, prison governors and other officials. They might have provided an insight into what the Thais, er,  thought about the situations you were filming. What happened to them?

JB: Yes. Yes. Indeed. And of course we took all their thoughts and advice on board, as one does. But you know in a programme with this demographic, and we are trying to reach and educate young people here, we do not want to ruin the flow with all that gibberish in some sort of ying tong language…And we have to think of the budget too you know. We would have had to pay more for translators, voice-overs or put up sub-titles. 

JF: So … basically the budget is split 50/50 is it?  50 per cent in the field, and 50 per cent back in the office?

JB: No … there’s a raft of other payments that have to be made.

JF: Under the banner of administration …

JB: “Quite, quite. For example there’s the payment to Mr Bremner …

JF: “What for exactly …?

JB: Well … er … executive input - naturally.

JF: Ah, ah … yes … yes.

JB: And then there’s Mr Bremner’s assistant.  And Mr Bremner’s assistant’s assistant.  And the assistant’s assistant’s assistant and then of course, we had to find a narrator for the programme.

JF: I see. And are narrators expensive?

JB: Well they can be you know if you hire a celebrity or well known newsman who has an air of authority?

JF: And is that what you did? I can’t say I recognized the voice.

JB: Well, er no. We considered George Michael but he was engaged. In this case we wanted a voice to which our target audience could relate to. Not some old fuddy fuddy out of touch with today’s younger generation. Not to put too fine a point on it somebody who can say, well pardon me here, somebody who can say (lowers voice) bum without feeling uncomfortable, and some other words too.

JF: Oh I see. So where did you get him from?

JB: Hampstead Heath, when we were looking for George Michael.  But then of course we had to educate him in the pronounciation of Thai place names, the same as a typical British chav on holiday in Thailand might say them, like Foo-ket, and this all costs money and time too, not to mention the lagers Vodkas and Red Bull etcetera.

JF: And there’s the executive input TOO?

JB: Exactly.

JF: So, what proportion of the overall budget of 400,000 Pounds would Mr Hill have received to make this series?

JB: Well, approximately one thirteenth.

JF: And was Mr Hill happy about that?

JB: Well, we assumed he would be …. but the blighter went over budget.

JF: So, in the end he spent about half the budget after all …?

JB: No … he spent about one tenth of the budget.

JF: Well, that seems pretty good going to me … you must have welcomed him back a hero?

JB: No, actually we fired him.  And threatened to sue him.

JF: Oh? On what grounds? 

JB: Gosh, where do you want me to start? For example he insisted on using new tape to film rather than re-using old tape.

JF:  Well, aren’t there good technical reasons for that … and tape’s relatively cheap, not like the old days of film and pretty damn vital too isn’t it?

JB: Well, yes … but of course you have to ensure there’s enough money for executive input.  And another thing he upset the Thai Government.

JF: Well, couldn’t you have forseen that in a series that examined the notorious sex industry, drunkenness and violence and was inevitably going to stumble across cases of corruption?

JB: Well, possibly …But then he put some unedited stuff up on the internet which upset our executives, who have been running around trying to get it off all sorts of websites.

JF: Sorry, I’m not with you?

JB: Well on a low budget production like this, often only having one camera, one just has to bring in sound and film from elsewhere for technical reasons. But we were made to look like we were creating well, not strictly true situations?

JF: But isn’t that what you did?

JB: Not at all. Not at all. Look the public don’t understand the intricacies of television making, and we would prefer it remained that way.
Actually I don’t understand them either, which is good because if I could make television programmes then the whole world could, and then where would we be?
Anyway the BBC are doing it all the time… Like the BBC we work on the principal of WYSIWYG. Or ‘What you see is what you get’. Only we then enhance it further to WWGYIWYG.

JF: W-W-G-Y-I-W-Y-G?

JB: ‘What we give you is what you get’, of course. That’s the Executive input. And it costs money.
JF: So, when exactly did the Thais get upset with your programme?

JB: Well, about the time we changed the title … from Thai Cops …

JF: What to?

JB: BIG TROUBLE in TOURIST Thailand.

JF: And Hill went along with this?

JB: Err … no, he protested. Vigorously, in fact.  And that’s another reason why we sacked him.  Because he was quite clearly a troublemaker.

JF: But of course changing the title wouldn’t have caused Hill any problems personally.  He could just come back to Blighty.

JB: Er … well … not quite … the Thais issued a warrant for his arrest and he was forced to flee the country leaving behind his home, his wife and child.

JF: So, you’ve had no choice but to stand by him and stand up for the integrity of the series and free speech?

JB: Well, no … on legal advice we’ve distanced ourselves from Mr Hill and withheld eight thousand pounds from his fee.

JF: Well surely it’s all a storm in a tea cup - it’ll all blow over in due course and Mr Hill can return to Thailand and get back on with his life?

JB: Well, very possibly.  But with the Thais you can never be 100 per cent certain.  Stories of chaps being flung into jail for getting on the wrong side of the rulers there and the key tossed away are not unusual.

Lardyao Prison

JF: So, let me get this straight … Mr Hill filmed in all these prisons and then the Thais threatened to put him in one.  How ironic?

JB: Ironic - yes.

JF: So, presumably you’ve hired a lawyer to defend Mr Hill.

JB. Er … no.  Actually we’ve hired a lawyer to sue Mr Hill.

JF: But of course now the show has aired on British TV you won’t want to inflame the situation further, possibly making life more difficult for Mr Hill, will you?

JB: No, of course not.  But you have to remember we have a commercial investment here.  We’ve already sold the series to Australia and we hope more countries round the world will snap it up.

JF: Australia!?  Isn’t Thailand one of the most popular tourism destinations for Australians?

JB: Yes … and the deadliest as it turns out … in fact we haven’t ruled out selling the format as well to the Australians so they can make their own version of the series.  Plenty of Australians falling foul of the law in Thailand … one Australian woman I gather was banged up for days merely for stealing a beer mat. Actually we have a few Aussie incidents left out of the original the edit. They certainly know how to party our colonial chums.

JF: The Thais won’t be very happy about that. But I assume, like here, the series will air on a little-watched niche cable channel?

JB: No, actually we’ve sold it to Channel 9, one of the biggest TV networks in the country.

JF: So, Virgin Media - isn’t that owned by Richard Branson?  What’s he had to say about it all, given that he has commercial interests in Thailand?

JB: Well, we’re rather hoping he hasn’t noticed.

JF: So, you must rue the day Mr Hill walked through your door with this idea.  Presumably as an independent film company you generate many commercial film ideas.

JB: Well, there’s a lot of competition.  We put our top man Dean Palmer onto it but in two years he found it very challenging.

JF: So, how many films did Mr Palmer get commissioned in two years - apart from Mr Hill’s that is?

JB: Well …. …. …. err …

JF: Ten, five … three …?

JB: Er , well just this one. But if he can do the same in the the Philippines where the Yanks  go, well then we’ve got Hollywood and bob’s your uncle.

JF:  And how much was Mr Palmer paid?

JB: Well too much of course, sixty thousand or so, but we pride ourselves on rewarding talent.

JF: For his executive input?

JB: Precisely.

JF: But it mustn’t have been too much of a worry to you because Vera’s trademark show Bremner Bird and Fortune is a much loved institution on the landscape of British TV.

JB: Well, indeed … but sadly it’s been axed this year.

JF: So, the company needs these sort of ventures?

JB: Yes, of course we’d rather stay with comedy, but like other companies you have to move with the times.

JF: But surely if you sue Mr Hill won’t other filmmaking hopefuls be reluctant to come to you?

JB: Well, we don’t think so and we set the agenda.  We would hope these people would put artistic integrity above financial gain.

JF: You mean you would like them to work for nothing?

JB: Well, in an ideal world yes.  On our website we state we do not pay for ideas. And you can’t put a price on fame.

JF: Nor executive input?

JB: Quite.

JF: George Parr - thank you very much.

———————————————————————-

Credits:

Pictures courtesy of Andrew Chant/Bravo/Fortune and Bird/Santhiya Hotel and Spa, Ko Phangnan:

Apologies for omitting pictures to:

Dream Hotel, Bangkok. “Heavenly slumber within five star accommodation.”

 Punpreeda Hip Resort, Koh Samui, ”designed with love and attention to detail. Splashes of colour ignite the soul”.

 Amari, Pattaya. “Soak in this scenic tropical panorama as you unwind on a shaded beach lounger, or drift into a blissful state of relaxation.”

British broadcasting ‘watchdog’ rejects complaint about ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ UPDATED

Has Ofcom ruled lies can’t hurt us? Rory Bremner has the last laugh.

Britain’s broadcasting watchdog ‘Ofcom’ has rejected complaints about the documentary series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ brought by the series producer himself.

In rejecting the complaint Ofcom says that Gavin Hill was not entitled to complain as he did not feature in the series, nor was he connected to the subjects of the series, Thai police, tourists, police volunteers etc.

Gavin Hill

Gavin Hill

A complaint by Hill that the series also falsely repeatedly stated that last year 288 Brits were killed in Thailand, when in fact that was the number of Brits who had just died in Thailand, was also rejected as Ofcom judged that this ‘would not  result in material harm to viewers ‘

The controversial series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ was originally sold by Hill as ‘Thai Cops’ to comedian Rory Bremner’s company Vera Productions and went out earlier this year on the ‘Bravo’ Channel in Britain.

Hill, former APTV chief in Singapore,  had complained that the company had failed to fact check when they edited in London and had made some unethical cuts to alter the reality of situations.

Dean Palmer Does he read his email?

Dean Palmer Does he read his email?

Roger Riach, the son of a Scots woman who died after being mugged in Bangkok has also complained about the television series. Despite the London executive producer Dean Palmer having been notified of her death, which in any case was widely reported in the press, the programme reported two weeks ago that Lydia Riach was still alive and Thai police were hot on the trail of her killer. They also named Dougie and Roger Riach, her husband and son, as ‘ Tony’ and ‘John’ without any explanation.

Said Gavin Hill: “This is just the sort of stuff I have been up against. I emailed Dean Palmer with the full update about Lydia’s death.”

 It is believed the report was included to replace another jet-ski incident,  after a showdown with Royal Marines in Phuket and a jet-ski operator,  caused wide controversy in Thailand

 The text of the Ofcom rejection follows below:

 Wed, 28 Oct 2009 23:51
Subject: Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand: Bravo Ref: 1-129444255
Dear Mr Hill
 
Thank you for submitting a fairness and privacy complaint form.
 
I note you are the programme maker of the series Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand but that you do not appear in nor are referred to in the programme.
In order to bring a complaint of unfair treatment in the programme as broadcast or unwarranted infringement of privacy in the making or broadcast of a programme, our criteria for “person affected” must be satisfied. In accordance with our procedures for handling fairness and privacy complaints (copy attached), the “person affected” is a person who is a participant in a programme and is the subject of the alleged unfair treatment or unwarranted infringement of privacy or has a direct interest in the subject matter of the alleged unfair treatment or unwarranted infringement of privacy and if a direct interest  then that the interest is sufficiently direct.
 
Having read your complaint, I note you were not a participant in the programme nor were you referred to. The subject matter of the programme complained of appears to be the work of the Thai Police authorities. As the programme maker you therefore do not have a direct interest in the subject matter of the programme.  Furthermore, the issues you raise are potential issues of unfairness in the making of the programme and this falls outside of Ofcom’s remit. Broadcasters have the right to editorial freedom when making programmes providing, in the case of fairness and privacy, it does not result in unfairness in the broadcast programme or unwarranted infringement of privacy in the making or broadcast of the programme to a “person affected”.
 
With regard to your complaint about accuracy relating to the opening statement in the programme that last year 288 Britons were killed in Thailand, this has been assessed under the Standards section of the Ofcom Broadcasting Code (“the Code”) under Harm and Offence.
 
We assess such matters against Rule 2.2 of the Code, which directs that factual programmes or items or portrayals of factual matters must not materially mislead the audience, but is intended to deal with content which materially misleads the audience so as to cause harm rather than accuracy per se.
While we acknowledge your distinction between describing someone being killed and dying, in this particular context, which was simply a factual reference to the number of deaths, we don’t judge this would result in material harm to viewers in the sense of our rules.
I am sorry that we cannot consider your complaint further but thank you for contacting Ofcom. 
 
Kind regards
 
 Julia Snape

Fairness & Privacy,Content & Standards

 

Comment: No surprises here but its nice to know that Ofcom appears to support the notion that false information cannot harm us.

Hill and Palmer when times were good!

Hill and Palmer when times were good!

But whatever happens these chaps will not be sitting in the same love-seat anymore.

The shot here was taken in happier times before Dean Palmer left to supervise the edit in the UK.

The R in Vera is Rory Bremner and the A is Geoff Atkinson, Bremner’s producer and partner in the company. Actually Geoff, with whom I have been in correspondence over BTIT, is one of Britain’s top comedy writers and producers and has written for Cannon and Ball, Ronnie Barker, as well of course from Bremner.

He has also made some serious investigative docs.

His series ‘Heil Honey I’m home’ based on Adolf Hitler and Eva Braun sharing a house in the suburbs was however taken off after one episode.

Well I can see the humour there, after all we have had the ‘Producers’, ‘Allo Allo’ and ‘Hogan’s Heroes all taking the fun out of the Nazis. Perhaps it was ahead of its time.

Dean Palmer is a different sort of fish to track down although his background on zoominfo includes such greats as ‘I’m a Celebrity Get me out of here’, ‘Survivor’, Dispatches etc,  Assignment and The Big Story further searches have revealed little more. However on Vera’s website he is listed as one of the company’s ‘two thinkers’. One of his programme’s ‘Sky Crimes’ was apparently short-listed for an Emmy, but when I looked up Sky Crimes he was not on the list of major credits which included producer or director.

Gavin Hill has more of a news background starting as sound broadcaster in Picaddily Radio, Manchester, he went on to be APTV’s man in Singapore and has reported from Afghanistan, Peru, and umpteen more places and we were both on the hunt for Nick Leeson.

He has also been a Hollywood TV reporter based out of LA, an instructor in television journalism,  worked for ‘Real TV and  subsequently even gave a talk once entitled: ‘Quality TV - My part in its downfall’, though I think (I hope) that was self effacement rather than a real statement of fact.

Mind you he does have a dark television secret involving a giant rubber ball and the Grand Canyon, I believe. I haven’t got to the bottom of that yet. :-)

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Camera director of ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ makes ‘tactical withdrawal’

 

From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok,
September 20 2009

Pictures Gavin Hill/Vera
A British producer cameraman has had to flee Thailand after filming a sequence in which British Royal Marines were held at gunpoint by Thai mafia after hiring a Jet Ski on a paradise beach.
The cameraman Gavin Hill, 40, from Manchester, a former bureau chief for Associated Press Television, was today back in London, after fleeing Bangkok, as his Thai crew faced up to a year in jail.
They stand accused of assisting in the filming of a sequence which could ‘damage the country’s image’.  A battle with the Thai authorities has raged for two weeks.
 Hill, who also produced ‘Crime Squad’ for the BBC with Sue Lawley, and a series for Real TV said today (Sunday) :  “I’ve made a tactitcal withdrawal  and am in London to discuss how we can help our Thai colleagues.  But yes, I did not wish to argue my case from prison.

Marine Tebbott, JJ, and producer cameraman Gavin Hill

Marine Tebbott, JJ, and producer cameraman Gavin Hill

“We filmed the mafia but suddenly we are the criminals apparently. The atmosphere is a little bit hysterical. The Marines are behind me thank god. ”
The gun incident happened on Phuket when a young marine Jack Tebbott  from Leicester was kidnapped by tattooed mafia figures, who control what’s for sale on Phuket’s  Patong Beach.
Twenty-one-year old Tebbott  was seized after his colleagues from Delta Company 40 Commando told a scammer to ‘get lost’ after they were presented with a bill for 60,000 Thai baht (£1094) for damaging  a jet ski which they had hired.
The marines, from  40 Commando based in Taunton,  have lost three men fighting the Taliban in Helmand province of Afghanistan. Delta section’s most famous Marine is Joe Townsend who lost his legs in a mine explosion. 
They had been warned about the scam and told not to hire jet skis  before after arriving on HMS Bulwark in June, but did not anticipate coming up against a gunman in a Thai holiday resort.
Gavin Hill had received permission from the Thai authorities to film a series called ‘Thai Cops’ , a reality show which followed British volunteers in the Thai Tourist Police dealing with the hundreds of thousands of  British tourists  who travel to Thailand every year.  However ,as a result of this incident and others, the title of the series had to be changed to ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’.
The Marines incident happened after producers received complaints from tourists and went to a Jet Ski operator called Winai Naiman, nicknamed JJ, to get his side of the story.
On camera he admitted beating up tourists if they did not pay.

The foreign and Thai production crew for 'Big Trouble in Thailand'

The foreign and Thai production crew for 'Big Trouble in Thailand'

Then he called the production crew to film after catching Marine Tebbot and taking to him his yard three miles from the beach.  Unknown to him Hill was also filming with the Marines.  Naiman brought out a gun with a telescopic sight after a section of Delta Company react to a distress call.
The affair was settled after the arrival of  Marine Police Sergeant  and Detatchment Commander Tim Wright, from London, who told Naiman his was ‘corrupt and a crook’ after examining the jet ski and finding the damaged area had already turned brown proving it was old.  But Sergeant Wright finally agreed to pay 35,000 baht, over £600.
Royal Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright said at the 40 Commando base in Somerset: “I got my men out of that situation without claret being spilt and that was the important thing.
“The Thais are trying to say my men were not threatened or held at gunpoint.  But by doing this they are questioning my integrity. I do not like my integrity being questioned especially by a two bit crook.
“We will make representations to the Foreign Office. The warning to tourists is not sufficient.
“ If Thailand wants to make a fuss about this I am happy to support the producer and raise the level to that of diplomatic incident.  The case of Marine Tebbott was not the only case of extortion I had to deal with, not by far.”
The Foreign Office advisory warns traveller to ensure that the people whom they hire jet skis from are reputable. But they do not warn specifically about the extortions involved and that violence has been used.
Tourists have been milked for as much as 200,000 bat during these incidents in Thailand according to a group of foreign consuls, who estimated on the Thai island of Koh Samui  jet ski operators, working with local police, had  scammed nearly £100,000 out of tourists between December and April of this year.
“In almost all cases the police are called they make the tourists pay out and then they get the commission from the jet ski operators.  In most cases it is old damage. In a case of new damage the cost of repair would not normally be more than £50, ” a local consul said on condition of anonymity.

Filming with Thai Tourist Police in Phuket

Filming with Thai Tourist Police in Phuket

A spokesman for the Thai film board said the crew had violated Article 34 of the motion picture law by not having the contents examined by a Tourism and Sports Ministry film committee before they were broadcast abroad.
And Seksan Nakawong, director-general of the Office of Tourism Development, said the film-makers also violated Article 23 of the same law for making a film tarnishing the reputation of Thailand.  The penalties are a £18,000 fine and a year in jail or both.
Meanwhile Police  Lt. Gen Santhan Chayanont, chief of Provincial Police Region 8, whose officers are accused of being involved in the scams,  says he has ordered his men to bring in all the Thai ‘collaborators’ .
40 Royal Marine Commando lost one  officer  Lt. John Thornton and two men, Marine David Marsh and Marine and Corporal Damian Mulvihill  during a seven month tour of duty fighting the Taliban in Helmand Province in 2008.

Royal Marine Joe Townsend

Royal Marine Joe Townsend

The actions  and conduct of Delta Company’s Marine Joe Townsend, who lost both his legs in a mine explosion in Afghanistan, have been held up in the UK as a shining example of courage of the British forces.

Marine Townsend recently accompanied Britain’s Prince Harry to New York to meet US serviceman who had lost limbs in Afghanistan and Iraq.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Karen Elephant Patrol -Andrew Drummond. See comments below

Karen Elephant Patrol -Andrew Drummond. See comments below

I apologise to the Thai people but blame the film-makers - JJ (updated)

 

HMS Bulwark in Phuket

HMS Bulwark in Phuket

Phuket jet-ski operator JJ Naiman apologised to the Thai people for disappointing them on national television tonight, but said he was tricked into appearing on the controversial British television series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand.”

 

The jet ski operator who was shown bringing a gun out on British Royal Marines from HMS Bulwark, who were on Phuket on R & R, said he had been misled into thinking the film was ‘good for tourism’.

And Channel 3 gave a sympathetic hearing to JJ’s claim that the gun incident was set-up.   He claimed the producer filmed him with the gun separately and then introduced it into his confrontation with the Royal Marine, 21-yr-old Jack Tebbott.

Producer Gavin Hill reacted to the claim with mild amusement. “I do have problems with the way this show is being put together but the gun incident is quite clear. It  is a rolling shot, there are no cuts except when JJ tells me to stop filming

 “Perhaps he wanted to impress the Marines to show them, look I can use a gun too, but they definitely took it as a threat and have already posted their views up on the internet.

Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright (right) confronts JJ

Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright (right) confronts JJ

 “JJ is talking to Tebbott when he sorts of jumps a little and heads towards his hut.  I follow with the camera rolling thinking, well I hope he is not just going to take a pee, then he takes out the gun and brings it out.

 “I think they thought, ‘Boy we are dealing with a loose cannon here, maybe a whacko!”

“If somebody wants to make an issue of this I think I am on pretty strong ground.

“We of course never told JJ we were making a film to promote tourism. We told him we were filming with the Thai police to show how Brits behave on holiday.

“Actually they day we met JJ he said he had just come out of jail for having no licences for his guns.”

 

 

 

The gun - don't those pale legs belong to Marines?

The gun - don't those pale legs belong to Marines?

Footnote: The editors in London did however move sound from another part of the video and put it over the point when JJ arrived with the gun. Gavin Hill has complained about this.

Here are his comments:

No -(this refers to my question. Did I get it wrong, was this not rolling footage?) but good detective work going on there,(noticing the sound had been changed picked up by one website here (www.thailandlandofsmiles.com)  which accords with what I told you about Vera moving the audio.

 

 

 

There is no cut from the moment JJ walks out of his hut-like place where he keeps his guns.

I tilted down with the camera when he said don’t film.  After that there’s the effect of the TV going on the blink.

Why did they put that in? Because JJ goes and puts the gun back in his hut and everything fizzles out - that was the climax.

I can upload the video tomorrow - have it here, if that would help.

In terms of the link below you are right - there is no cut between JJ emerging with the gun, hidden behind his back and approaching the Marines, during which time I’m focused on the gun.

Anyway, the point is - in the midst of negotiations, whilst awaiting Tim, MP -  JJ produces the gun and the Marines are justifiably rattled.  They were, they said so at the time and have posted as much since.  But they weren’t scared out of their wits because, I guess, they’re used to being around guns and I think they’re quite smart, level-headed chaps not prone to panic.

I was worrying at the time far more than the Marines were.

Hope this clears things up.  The fact remains that Vera did over-sensationalize this clip by moving the earlier audio over to JJ approaching the Marines, gun in hand.  I am troubled by this, but aside from dramatic effect I’m not sure it alters what was an unnerving and unpredictable situation with a drunken lout backed up by thugs, holding a man to ransom and demanding cash from him.  The gun was an unnecessary addition and escalation to the proceedings and JJ only has himself to blame for that - whatever his motive was for bringing out the gun.  And it’s the only moment where I’m filming without his consent - that said he was to cover it all with a blanket release form.

 

Thai jet ski boss took cash off the US Marines too.

USS Boxer - US Navy Jon Rasmussen

USS Boxer - US Navy Jon Rasmussen

A now notorious Thai jet-ski operator accused of ripping off British Royal Marines in the infamous ‘damaged jet ski scam’ also took cash off US Marines in an incident just days later – and was ‘wai-ed’ by one US Marines in an apparent plea for lenience.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

'I'm so sorry sir, I will pay back I promise' Marine tells JJ

'I'm so sorry sir, I will pay back I promise' Marine tells JJ

The US Marines from the  Boxer ARG (Amphibious Readiness Group)  which made a call in Phuket just three days after HMS Bulwark had left,  handed over the cash without even a protest – because, believes film producer Gavin Hill, they had disobeyed an order banning them from hiring the machines..

Pay out

Pay out

The US Marines were then handed over  to the Naval Police as Thai police watched,  after payment of 40,000 baht was handed over by a Naval police officer who asked for receipts, after the Marines used their credit cards. They later faced disciplinary proceedings.
“You’re going to have trouble when you get on board,”  JJ tells one of the US Marines.
Gavin Hill, who faced allegations made to police by JJ  (who was subsequently arrested for extorting 35,000 Baht of the Royal Marines) that he had set up an earlier incident with the Royal Marines, who were seen to be held at gunpoint, today released more footage obtained during the filming of ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ as the controversy raged across Thai TV stations.
“I have released this material so that nobody can be in any doubt that any of these sequences were set up. I just shot as things happened. I should not have needed to defend my integrity, but it has now become an issue and I have to deal with it,” said producer/cameraman Hill.

With police in attendance JJ prepares his bill

With police in attendance JJ prepares his bill

The film begins with an interview with JJ being asked what has happened as he waits with a group of Marines on Patong seafront in Phuket on June 26th.
“It’s serious damage. We have to make a new bottom. If we can’t make new bottom the jet-ski will sink.
“If a boat gets a hole it will sink.”
He claims later the Marines ran the boat over some rocks.
JJ estimates the damage at 70,000 to 80,000 Thai baht, but again the damage to paint on the boat’s hull does not seem , from images, to be that costly to repair.
“They have agreed to pay for it, but they do not know how much. They give too little money,” says JJ.
As a group of US Marines wait, a large naval patrol officer arrives having been called by mobile phone.  There is no

No protest

No protest

issue.   The Marines have to pay he says.  There will be no argument. He has a short discussion with JJ.
As the group waits for police to arrive a young Latino Marine wais to JJ saying:  “I’m so sorry sir.  I’m sorry. I’ll pay back I promise.”
The arrival both of Patong ’Beach Patrol’ and a motorcycle officer is met with much wai-ing and saluting.  The Naval policeman counts out the cash to the ‘manager’ and the US Marines are handed into the custody of Naval Police.
Another bad day in paradise.
Said Gavin Hill: “It was quite a different situation that that of the Royal Marines.  The US Marines did not want the cameras.  They also knew, I believe, that, as they had breached an order, they could not argue. I have no idea whether they caused the damage or not, but they admitted it. They clearly did not want any trouble.”

“JJ said it would take two weeks to repair the boat. In the meant

Bt40,000 worth of damage

Bt40,000 worth of damage

ime he had to charge a day rate also for loss of earnings.”

Gavin Hill insists that the Thai authorities have overreacted to the British television series and says he had no  intention of hurting Thailand, but filmed what was in front of him.

The first in an eight part series called ‘Trouble in Tourist Thailand’ went out last Monday and showed how Royal Marines had to hand over 35,000 baht to JJ, even though, claimed Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright it was ‘old damage’.
Thai authorities have announced a crackdown on the scams, although there is evidence they may have been part and parcel of them.

Next stop the gangplank?

Next stop the gangplank?

 

Footnote: The highest known payment made by tourists in this scam has been 200,000 on Koh Samui. That involved a collision between two Jet skis.   Unless you  know better.

British Royal Marines ready to go to ‘war’ over Thai gun confrontation

(More rushes from ‘Big Trouble in Thailand)

“Thailand is awesome. The people are good and sound. Today was a bit different” - Marine Jack Tebbott

Link: JJ: My uncle is big Captain in police station
From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, September 13
Royal Marines who claim they were swindled and held at gunpoint while on R&R in Thailand said tonight that they were ‘ready to go to war’ over an alleged cover-up of the incident.

Royal Marine Face-offThe Marines of Delta Company, 40 Commando, based in Taunton, who were held at gunpoint by a Jet Ski operator on the Thai holiday island of Phuket, said they would take the matter to government to government level, if Thai authorities tried to shift the blame.
And they added that they would stick by a British producer/cameraman, who filmed the whole incident, and who now faces arrest  accused by the Thai authorities of ‘setting up’ the scene for filming.
“The Thai authorities should choose to hold an adult approach to this incident. If not, we are willing to raise the level of this dispute to that of a diplomatic incident, though of course we will have to go through legal channels,“ said Marine Police Sergeant and Detachment Commander Tim Wright.
The row follows an incident which happened when Delta Company were on ‘R &R’ on the Thai holiday island of Phuket earlier this year.

Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright (right) confronts JJ

Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright (right) confronts JJ

The marines were held at gun-point and surrounded by Thai thugs after one of their number, 21-yr-old Marine Jack Tebbott, from Leicester, was accused of damaging  a jet-ski and faced demands of over £1,200 in compensation.
Violence was only avoided when Royal Marine Police Sergeant Tim stepped and agreed to authorise a payment.

Marine Sergeant Tim Wright

Marine Sergeant Tim Wright

The whole scene was captured on film by British cameraman producer Gavin Hill. The Jet Ski thug, known as JJ, has since been arrested on charges of extortion. But he has given a statement saying that the film was set up.
Yesterday Thai authorities began steps to try and block a series currently running on a minor British television  channel and they said they wanted to question the producer over the ‘set up’.
They have also countermanded all ‘film release’ forms which were required for the filming and transmssion. Last night Royal Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright from London said: “From what I gather people in Thailand are trying to impugn the reputation of the Royal Marines and of the producer cameraman involved.
“I have told the producer cameraman Gavin Hill that I and the lads will stand by him. What he recorded on film was the absolute truth.  I do not like my integrity or that of the Marines being questioned. I live by my integrity.
“I especially do not like my integrity being questioned by a two bit swindler.  If need be we will escalate this to a diplomatic incident.  We also would like to the Foreign and Commonwealth Office to put out an official warning on their Travel Advisory to Thailand.
“It is quite alarming to see how the film maker s are being treated. The Thais should be dealing with the problem not trying to blame someone else.”
The row over the ‘jet ski mafia’ began after the first of an eight part series called ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ went to air last Monday on the Bravo Channel.  The film shows the Commandos, who had arrived in Thailand on HMS Bulwark after a tour in Afghanistan’s Helmand Province, restraining themselves as the armed foul mouthed gang leader made his threats and demands for money.

Marine Jack Tebbott

Marine Jack Tebbott

Although the channel has only a small audience in the UK, copies have been circulating heavily in Thailand.
In the programme Marine Tebbott is accused of causing over £1000 worth of damage to a jet ski and eventually pays out the equivalent of £627.  But Sergeant Wright, who examined the boat, insisted that the damage was old, very old, by examining the stained fibre glass”
He had already had to deal with other cases: “‘You are a crook. You are corrupt,” he tells JJ who replies: “I’m a f….g normal person. I am a businessman”.  In rushes released yesterday JJ also claims: “I’m not worried. My uncle is big police here!”
 A Royal Marine said later: “We could all have got out of there but there would have been claret spilt.”

The ‘damaged jet ski’ con is widespread in Thailand and complaints have already been made by several Embassies, including the British, Australian and Chinese, to the Thai authorities.

Prior to the film’s transmission the Provincial Governor had been ordered by Thailand’s Deputy Prime Minister to act to end the rip-offs to preserve the country’s image for tourism.

 Reliable reports say that corrupt police take a 20 per cent cut from all payments.

Gavin Hill - hung out to dry?

Gavin Hill - hung out to dry?

Meanwhile producer Gavin Hill, who was working for comedian Rory Bremner’s Vera Productions, said: “At the moment our relationship has come to an end.  They have not given any support. They are also not honouring some promises I made to the Thai authorities or corrections I am making to the scripts. 

“They appear to have left me out to dry. The Thai authorities are trying to get the series stopped.  But actually if they look at it closely they come off quite well.  We were primarily looking at British tourists on holiday. 
“I actually love Thailand and would not wish to harm the country at all. The authorities cannot see who is doing the harm.”

The series which was shot with the co-operation of the Thai Tourist Police was originally called ‘Thai Cops’. The title was then changed to ‘Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand’ and the Thai Film Board protested.
“I told the production company that title was offensive to Thailand, but my views were apparently not ‘taken on board’ as they claimed they would be. It’s a mess.
““The situation with the Marines and JJ was real and menacing. It was not set up or scripted. I just recorded what happened”.

JJ's boys look on

JJ's boys look on

 

 

.

The Great Thai jet ski tourist scam - a producer bares all

The series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ has provoked quite a controversy across the internet blogs in this part of the world and is now begining to hit the mainstream Thai media.

Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright confronts JJ

Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright confronts JJ

Accusations have been made. Was the confrontation with the Marines set up? What sort of guy is JJ – the Thai mafia figure featured in this seemingly shaming episode for the Thai tourist industry.
Anyway Gavin Hill the producer/director is throwing the issue wide open.  He says he has not formed a judgment, but of course the film had to be cut and edited, and it is apparent that although his comments were ‘taken on board’, perhaps not all were acted upon.
You can form your own opinion of JJ by clicking on the following links.
 We all get edited. Make your own mind up. 

Of course JJ may seem worse!  Personally I may have cut the film in pretty much the same way, I think the producer is entitled to make a judgment.   We start today with JJ on the beach whinging about bad tourists.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gzeui3rC5yo

and continue with him whinging on the beach. I rather picked up on the piece where JJ said : ” We call the police”

http://www.youtube.com/user/BigTroubleInThailand#play/all/uploads-all/1/yFJsyJccTWE

He believes a lot of foreigners have money to spare. He just needs to feed his family.

They come off the beach tomorrow, Saturday, not before time, when I am sure we will hear about JJ’s police contacts!

 Meanwhile JJ has not sold himself to me, although to be sure there are some idiots hiring jet skis from time to time.

Arrest follows ‘extortion’ of Royal Marines in Thailand

Arrest follows British television documentary

From Andrew Drummond, Bangkok, September 9th 2009
Pictures: Andrew Chant/Gavin Hill/

 

Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

Thai authorities have arrested the leader of a Thai mafia gang and charged with him with extortion based solely on the evidence of a British television documentary.
Police today were holding a Thai known locally a JJ Naiman, aged 27, after he was seen on a British television programme trying to extort over £1000 from a British Royal Marine who had rented a jet-ski on the holiday island of Phuket.
The province’s governor Wichai Praisa-nob also stepped into the row today and called a meeting of police, jet-ski operators, Marine Police, and local government officials to discuss what action would be taken. They are also to be shown the film. He said he was considering banning jet skis from the island.
The British documentary ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’, which went to air on  Monday on the Bravo Channel, showed Royal Marines, who arrived in Phuket on HMS Bulwark, after a tour of Helmand Province, Afghanistan, being held at gun point in a local boat yard run by local mafia.
Royal Marine Face-offThe row was only resolved after the arrival of Marine Police Sergeant Tim Wright who defused the situation but not before exposing the Thai gangleader  as a ‘corrupt crook’.  The Marine Jack Tebbott, 21, from Leicester (right) eventually paid just over £600.
Tim Wright said: “These men openly threatened serving military personnel whilst on R&R in Thailand. The important thing is that I got them out of there with no one being hurt, other than pride and in the wallet. I don’t remember swearing but apologise if I did! The other important thing to remember is don’t hire jet skis in Thailand.”
The jet-ski con is widespread. Tourists are forced to pay for damage which they clearly have not created, but the mafia gangs have had assistance from corrupt police officers, who, according to one source, claim 20 per cent. 

Copies of the programme are now widely available on the internet.   Further programmes could also embarrass Thailand.  A well known police rip-off on the island of Koh Phangan where police collect £10,000 every month from touriRoyal Marine Face-offsts on minor drugs charges on the threat of having to go to jail pending trial, is already getting exposure.  
The boyfriend of one girl arrested says he received a demand to find £1,400 for possessing a small amount of cannabis, others had to pay more. For normal Thais the fine can be as little as £50.
And a similar jet ski scam will also be exposed on the Thai island of Koh Samui.
British Producer Gavin Hill said: “This was not designed to be an investigative programme. We just filmed what was going on in front of us.”
He said however the next programme in the series probably reflected more on bad British behavior than that of Thais.

“I am a little surprised at the big reaction now. This seems to have been going on for a long time.”

JJ Naiman has been refused bail. Allegations that he had been paid to help set up the scene were described by Gavin Hill as ‘hardly credible’. “We had to cut a lot of the footage. I am satisfied that what was presented was the absolutely correct portrayal of the situation.  I have not taken any side.”

Picture Special: Royal Marines in stand-off with Thai mafia

 
Picture special:
 by Andrew Drummond, Bangkok

Pictures: Andy Chant/Gavin Hill/Vera Productions

Royal Marine Face-off

(pops rewrite)
Royal Marines fresh from a tour of duty fighting the Taliban in Afghanistan have been involved in armed stand-off with the mafia thugs on the Thai holiday island of Phuket.
The marine ‘section’,  on exercise in South East Asia on ‘Operation Taurus’, faced down a mafia gun-man as they fought the same cause of hundreds of tourists who have been swindled at the top British holiday destination.

I gotta get me a gun

I gotta get me a gun

The only reason blood was not spilled was because a Marine Police Sergeant stepped in to avoid a major international incident as the marines faced off with armed and tattooed Mafiosi who had been beating up tourists and ripping them off for thousands of pounds.
Trouble began after HMS Bulwark made a port call in Phuket two months ago with the Marines who had just completed a tour of duty in Helmand Province.
Within hours Shore Patrol policeman Matt Turner from Sheffield was reporting. “It’s mayhem.  Our lads, and hundreds of westerners are being fleeced and we believe it’s all by organised gangs.  Jet skis, taxis, everything.
He added: “We have to help. We will do it whether its Marines or tourists being ripped off. We do not differentiate.”
The boisterous Marines were officially warned by their officers not to hire jet skis on the beaches of the holiday island as this was the most expensive rip-off of all. Thailand has been hard hit by a tourist recession.
But confident they could handle the situation, many ignored the ruling.

Marine Jack Tebbott

Marine Jack Tebbott

Not long afterwards Marine 21-yr-old Jack Tebbott from Leicester found himself staring down the barrel of a gun after being taken to a  builders and boating yard in the back of beyond,  after allegedly damaging a jet-ski he had hired. The mafia were demanding 60,000 Thai baht £1,400 in damages and loss of earnings.
Several tourists have already been beaten up for refusing to surrender to the mafia demands.
Surrounded by the stripped to the waist thugs and held at the point of a rifle Tebbot had managed to get an sms message to his mates who arrived at the yard near Patong Beach on Phuket in ‘section force’.
Bloodshed was only avoided when Marine Police Sergeant and Detatchment Commander Tim Wright arrived on the scene and told Tebbot: “Ok lad we told you not to hire jet skis. We know it’s a con but I’m afraid you’re now going to have to pay some money to get out of this.”

No nonsense Marine Sgt Tim Wright

No nonsense Marine Sgt Tim Wright

Then  after examining the jetski the no nonsense Sergeant, who had already had to deal with other cases, turned on the mafia chief called JJ and said: “You’re a crook!  You’re corrupt.  The damage is old. The fibre glass has already turned brown.  How come all your jet-skis have a problem?”
Then he turned to Marine Tebbot and said: “Ok boy. You go now!”
JJ then ordered his thugs to block Tebbot’s exit but JJ perhaps sensing he had a fight on his hands continued negotiating.    The price eventually dropped by almost a half to 35,000 baht to (£627) but not before some other heated exchanges.
“I’m just a f…cking businessmen. F..ck. You.  How are we to feed our families,” said JJ pointing to his fellow thugs lounging around and waiting for their next sucker.
: ‘F..k you. You are not my father. You are not my pa.
Sgt:“Don’t shout at me. You’re  crook. You’re a worm. You’re doing this day after day.

Marine policeman Mat Turner

Marine policeman Mat Turner

 

JJ:F.. ck you!
Sgt: F.ck you!’.
The standoff ended when Marine Tebbot agreed to foot the bill. “Ok,” said Sergeant Wright,” you better toddle of to the ATM then.
The Marines conceded afterwards that it was £627 too much but worth it to avoid an international incident.
Said Sergeant Wright:  “They are trained to be cool. But had it come to the crunch we could have easily fought them and got all our lads out of there.  But there would have been some claret spilt on both sides.”

 

 

Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

Face off Royal Marine Police Sergeant Wright and JJ

 The stand-off did however have a happy ending. After complaints from the British and other Embassies in Phuket the island’s police chief has ordered a crackdown on the thugs,  on the orders of Thailand’s Deputy Prime Minister, admitting that some policemen had also been pocketing cash with the local mafia.
Police Commander Pigad Thantiphong , who admitted that the Royal Navy had also made a complaint  through the Embassy said: “Anyone who threatens tourists from now on will be prosecuted.  Any policeman who assists the mafia will be punished, and independent experts will be brought in to adjudicate in any case.”

But how do we feed our families?

But how do we feed our families?

Amazingly the Marines standoff was captured on film by producer/director Gavin Hill which can be seen tonight(Monday) 10 pm in ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ made by comedian Rory Bremner’s Vera Productions for Bravo Channel  and filmed with the Thai Tourist Police.

It was like this - you want to teach ME the art of public debating

It was like this - you want to teach ME the art of public debating

 

And despite the incident many marines still thought Phuket was the best place they had taken shore leave in.

Big Trouble in Tourist Thailand

The last time Royal Marines had a fight in Phuket

Foreign Tourist Police Volunteers Exposed

howardmillerbv

Big Trouble in Thailand - Bravo Channel UK

This is a blog only
(Warning this article comes with a drop-intro)

I have a love-hate relationship with television.  Once in a blue moon I do a documentary then almost immediately afterwards, after the initial elation (because I almost always think they are good)  I vow never to do another one again, remembering the nightmare making it.
I would say it’s like having a baby, if I knew.  (I do know where they come from).

Picture above: Howard Miller/Bravo

What usually infuriates me is the hassles of commissioning editors , executive producers, the politicking, and all the conditions put on filming… as if they want to take ownership just because they are providing the cash. There’s  logic there, but I could never quite agree with it. 
Then there’s those long shoots and edits and the problem of trying to keep everybody together.  Watching the ‘camera director’ trashing the ‘Video or Film Editor’ is not a pretty sight.  And again there’s all these phrases used in Covent Garden wine-bars;  ’production values’ , ’speaking from a higher level plain’ etc. etc
Currently expats in Thailand are a little bit up in arms about a documentary series going to air in the UK over the next few weeks called ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’ and it’s based on the activities of the British Thai Tourist Police Volunteers and what we commonly know in the British newspaper business as, well, ‘Brits in the shit’. And its taken two years to get off the ground.
“This is going to be more salacious crap’. ‘It’s going to make Thailand look bad’. ‘It’s going to make us all look bad’.  ‘Another nail in my coffin. My wife thinks I just come here for a golfing holiday’ These sort of comments are going up on expatriate internet forums.
Does it do all that?  Well it certainly makes some people look bad. It certainly makes some tourists, British and others, look profoundly stupid.  But as for tourism, my guess is that young Brits having seen the series will be gagging to get here….and they are the film’s demographic! …’Thailand?  Dull it isn’t ‘ should be the TAT’s new slogan.
Of course that might sound all a bit like the famous Pattaya short-time bar owner,  who after being exposed in a British Sunday newspaper put up a sign saying ‘Still just as sleazy as  featured in the News of the World’.  Seriously though, one can’t really get indignant at a series which reminds us of just how tourism has developed in Thailand.
Actually the series, which goes out on the ‘Bravo Channel’ in the UK next week, is a first class presentation of many of the different facets of youth tourism in Thailand.  And, as it is based on the British members of the Tourist Police Volunteers, we know which side we are going to see.  It’s not going to be old grannies asking police for directions to the Temple of the Emerald Buddha.

Gavin Hill undercover in Pattaya

Gavin Hill undercover in Pattaya

I have to declare a bias. I like the style of Gavin Hill, the producer and we have many joint friends. He has also bought me a beer or two. He is an old Asia hand, having worked for APTV first of all in Indonesia, Al Jezeera, and many US production companies; well just about everywhere.
Actually he has worked for so many people like me he has probably become unemployable, because we probably don’t ever want to be employed any more. But he still wants to chase a good story. He is a class operator.  I am amazed at what he got on tape without somebody from somewhere throwing a punch.

Producing a professional video camera in Pattaya’s Walking Street is never a picnic. As cameras pan,  rows of male tourists duck, the rest tend to come at you.. often each with a beer bottle in hand.

But that’s maybe because Howard Miller, the Pattaya Group Leader of the foreign police volunteers, and his mates were around for protection.  And as for  Howard Miller.  Here’s a chap I have underrated!

Gruppenfuhrer Howard Miller is a lot more relaxed in Pattaya's walking street in a Home Guard sort of way

Gruppenfuhrer Howard Miller is a lot more relaxed in Pattaya's walking street in a Home Guard sort of way

I may have referred to him in the past as the ‘Gruppenfuhrer’, mainly because of his jet black uniform which some people say makes them all look like Nazi storm-troopers.
There’s no better or worse libel than calling someone a Nazi. I have been sued before for calling a Polish Resistance fighter a Nazi.

( I named and photographed the right guy. There was just a Polish guy with a very similar name nearby.  The newspaper paid out £500 with a clarification saying something like Stanslwz Jankievizx of 2 Railway Cuttings is a former Polish freedom fighter and is not the same Stanslwz  Jankievizk  the sadistic former Nazi concentration camp guard who lives down the road at 2 Junction Lane)

Anyway Howard comes across, and I am sure it is genuine, as a rather likeable, albeit sensitive, chap who is just doing his bit and more than happy to go out of his way to help those with problems no matter how thankless the task is. He gets an awful lot of internet slagging from expatriates for taking up his Tourist Police assistant role, perhaps because the police in Thailand are not associated with old British values like ‘fair play’.

I was only left puzzling. Why do it? Why bother? I still remain justifiably cynical of some of these volunteers but not those shown on the progamme. I guess Gavin Hill sniffed em out!

Anyway being a little cynical  I am convinced that more than a few middle-aged ex-pats in Thailand came to settle after seeing the first amateurish attempts of these fly-on-the-wall shows years ago in their homelands which featured bars with names like ‘The Gobble and Go’ and ‘Cockwell Inn’, before police started polishing up on their slang English.

What is amazing is that nobody ever gets it.  The same mistakes happen year in year out. Why do people bother going to ‘Full Moon Parties’ on Koh Phagnan?  I gave up 18 years ago!  Here in this series we see how rapes, muggings, druggings and of course arrests occur, every time, not forgetting the drownings and occasional murder.
Why don’t tourists do a little research on places they are going to?  (I always do) Or do they know and treat Thailand as an adventure holiday? As a parent I might be worried.
And if you get thrown out of a brothel  for being drunk, why report it to police? Its amazing how drink begets moral outrage.

Although the programme does pull punches (they are working with the police after all) we can clearly see the monthly police rip offs as they cash in on their monthly ‘Full moon arrests’…Pay the cash or go to jail!  A young kid sobs out a month in jail waiting to be fined £20. They can’t film those who agree to play the money game but we hear the prices being demanded. 65,000 Thai baht - £1,666 - for possessing a smidge of cannabis - that’s a lot more than the 2,000 baht (under £40)  the motorcycle guy at the end of my lane paid recently for a similar offence!

Its just another version of the well publicised Suvarnabhumi airport scam. (For those unfamiliar with this foreigners arrested on suspicion of shoplifting in the duty free stores were shaken down for as much as £8000 or face up to a year in jail facing trial alone)
We also see an American serviceman high on methamphetamines attacking a senior Thai policeman, and then the camera cuts on police orders, leading one to suspect that this shipmate is just about to learn the more discreet police version of  another aspect of Thai street culture  when foreigners are drunk or lippy-  It involves a lot of loud stomping by a frenzied and rabid mob.  I have seen it a few times. You don’t want to.

 ’There are Pattaya bar girls chasing, now well-outnumbered foreigners down the street shouting ‘You. You. Give me  money’; then the drunken Australian being thrown very roughly out of a brothel. ‘They stomped my head in’, he wails then lunges at Howard.  Then Howard is seen politely asking his father on the boy’s phone phone to come and collect him, all the while being called a ‘dickhead’ by the son. Gormless foreigners being led by their penises into oblivion.
There are of course lots and lots of drunks actually, and the British seem to score high here, later happily signing their film release forms, I guess as if signing for a medal. There is also titillation as skimpily dressed go-go girls frolic around poles in Pattaya bars. Well that is how it is,  so don’t whinge about it to me.
This is not a film series about fancy spas and lush jungle resorts and so called Hi-So launch parties with twee people.  One can get that sort of  fur coat and no knickers production on ‘Destination zzzz Thailand zzzzzz’. But this is still the real stuff that even high rolling tourists must find difficult to avoid.

Tooled up apparently - The film crew with armed escort - armed against resident expats

Tooled up apparently - The film crew with armed escort - armed against resident expats

Gavin Hill and his team secured excellent co-operation from the Thai authorities and I mean truly excellent and unprecedented access.

They got into seven jails and spoke to young Brits about how they were coping, quite pragmatically actually as it turns out, with their predicament.

 They also got help from Britain’s Honorary Consuls, those chaps who don’t get UK salaries for helping helping out, and who thankfully are far removed from Whitehall, ‘elf and safety’, and the ‘What we cannot do for you rule book’.  They include  Dave Covey on Koh Samui, and I suspect to come Barry Kenyon MBE in Pattaya.
 And of course they got help from Thai police, although they were seemingly treated with deep suspicion on Koh Samui and Koh Phangan (island folk you know. I go to these places cautiously).

 “ I think they took the view, why not? People coming to Thailand should know that if they behave badly or commit crimes the punishments will be severe. They should see the jails, and the police station lock-ups, and how they behave” said Gavin. 

I am probably a little jealous of the excellent results but then again I could not have done it. I fear my face is linked to too much trouble already!  I do not need some guy from the Blind Beggar saying to his mates ‘Ere. That’s the geezer what turned over Phil the Till” last year.”

This series also shows what police have to put up with, night after night,  for their, sometimes ill-gotten, rewards. All in all Thai police come out okay. There are some good eggs.
Britain’s  only saving grace, outwith the volunteers,  in the first part of this eight programme series, comes from the Royal Marines who arrive at Phuket on HMS Bulwark.

HMS Bulwark

HMS Bulwark

As the sailors disembark for shore leave they are advised not to hire jet-skis on Patong Beach.  But at this stage they are advised only. US military are banned from hiring them.
We cut to a scene where a young Marine is banged up in some sort of builders-yard-come-boat-warehouse in the back of beyond.  He faces a gun.   It’s either pay up or face the consequences. The Thai jet-ski operator is demanding 44,000 baht (£798)  for damage to his boat. Its a scam and a nasty one.
The Thai  boss ‘JJ’ makes it known on camera that he will resort to violence and has done in the past.
Around the scene are heavily tattooed Thais stripped to the waist.
More Marines arrive. Then along comes the ship’s Military Police Sergeant Major.
JJ insists on his cash, raising his voice as his 1% of  integrity slips to Norway’s initial average scores in the European Song Contest, but that’s a little difficult to maintain anyway in his tacky lair.

‘I’m a f..cking businessman!’
‘Don’t you shout at me!  You’re corrupt. You’re a  f…cking crook. This damage is old damage.  It’s turned brown already!’ shouts the Sergeant Major at JJ, ‘How come this happens every single day here!”

The Royal Marines must miss the water quickly. Lots of them have been hiring jet-skis apparently.
 

I wanted to shout a few more expletives at the little worm on the screen myself.

‘Go now!’  The Sergeant orders the poor unfortunate captive Marine to leave the scene.  JJ then orders his neanderthal  buddies to close in.
There’s a stand off.  The Marines are ready to fight their side.  It’s clear there are links between the local mafia and local police.  But at the end of the day the Marines know they cannot start an incident.

Eventually the Navy agree to pay a lesser amount,  but only because the young Royal Marine had been bullied into agreeing to it verbally earlier.  Series producer Gavin Hill was of course in the middle of this stand-off which would have cost a fortune to reconstruct with actors, and this was the real menacing truth.
The Royal Marines had just come from Helmand Province.  I admired their patience. ( But I guess  or rather I know they let some steam off in Soi Bangla where the military police were trying to save ‘Our boys’  from drooling ladyboys). 

 The Sergeant Major’s contempt was palpable, just as if he had just gobbled down a a couple of those ‘Brussels Sprouts’ which the ship’s HMS Bulwark’s Captain has apparently put down as ‘an enemy of the state’ and banned from his quarters.
I almost started singing ‘Rule Brittania’. A pyrrhic victory for the Thai thug accompanied by a trashing, sadly, for Thai tourism.
Coincidentally this week the Governor of Phuket has stepped into the local jet-ski rip-offs row.
Punters are paying up to £50 for half an hour on these machines,  then ripped off for up to £1000 for alleged damage, which includes loss of alleged earnings while the jet-ski is being repaired. 
The first programme in the series ‘Big Trouble in Thailand’, Vera Productions for the Bravo Channel, goes to air on Monday.  Better than a lot, and I mean a lot, on the mainstream channels, it’s as good an introduction to the non glossy side of tourism  in Thailand that you’ll ever get,…. but the beaches and the ‘craic’ still look great. I would want to go and have a look. Its a voyeurs paradise if nothing else. 

The only thing annoying to me was the way this was dressed up with bells and whistles, which everybody seems to do today to grab the viewers attention. Britain has long since been going the American way to keep the audience’s atttention span. (At Fox TV a sound grab was about five seconds max after which their American viewers apparently fall asleep, or go out for a Bud!)

I can live with this popular style, with the way several stories are interwoven, with a little bit of repetition, as if we have already forgotten, as in “remember Howard’ who is waiting for forensice reports on the drugs he has found (repeat sequence)..well now back to”…. After all I remind myself writing for the tabloids is harder than writing for the ‘unpopulars’ and of course the programme makers are going to the widest possible audience.

Overall I could not get enough of this and pray the series has not all been frontloaded.

Journalistically this series is a great coup because, even though its brief was not an investigative one, it only takes a bit of sense to see a what is revealed a little beyond the screen. You may not get the nuances if you still intend to hire a jet-ski in Phuket.